Brazil’s Teen Pregnancy Study Suggests Issue Needs a Different Approach

Efforts to reduce teen pregnancy rates in Brazil have shown mixed results, and new research from US’s Vanderbilt University suggests that the recent growth of psychological approaches to teen pregnancy prevention may have detrimental effects.

Teen pregnancy has traditionally been seen as a problem linked to poverty, low educational opportunities and family dysfunction.

In recent years, researchers have linked teen pregnancy to measures of developmental immaturity, sexual risk-taking and long-lasting depression.

This new body of research has started influencing the content of teen pregnancy prevention campaigns.

“As in other countries, Brazilian experts have long been implementing health education campaigns to encourage young people to delay parenthood by focusing on the social risks of early child-bearing, namely education outcomes and employment prospects,” said Dominique Pareja Béhague, associate professor of medicine, health and society at Vanderbilt.

“But now these campaigns are talking much more about psychological risks and consequences, such as the fact that teen mothers appear to be at greater risk of prolonged anxiety and depression.”

Béhague’s new paper, along with two previous publications, explores some of the unintended consequences of these discourses and campaigns, including an increased sense of marginalization and discrimination among youth, even before they become sexually active or pregnant.

The study, “Psychiatry, Sex, and Science: The Making of ‘Adolescent’ Motherhood in Southern Brazil,” was published by Medical Anthropology on April 28.

Béhague found that teachers, clinicians and psychologists who interact with young people now frequently tell them about the psychological and developmental risks of teen pregnancy as part of their efforts to encourage contraceptives and delay parenthood.

That approach needs serious reconsideration, Béhague said.

“Public health programs and discourses, though well-intentioned, are burdened with very negative images of teen mothers and of sexually active teens,” Béhague said.

“We found that young people are understandably quite sensitive to and even insulted by the implicit messages they encounter in these programs.”

The psychological experiences of teen moms are more varied than is generally assumed, Béhague added.

“In our study, many teen mothers experienced no lasting emotional difficulties,” she said. “For those who did, we found that stigma and discrimination were more influential than psychological characteristics, single motherhood or even low income. Public health approaches can easily exacerbate rather than alleviate these social stigmas.”

“Public health campaigns should address the broader social structures that stigmatize teen childbearing.”

Béhague has conducted long-term anthropological and epidemiological research in collaboration with researchers at the Department of Social Medicine at the Federal University of Pelotas in southern Brazil, who initiated and continue to direct The 1982 Pelotas (Brazil) Birth Cohort Study.

This study has been following representative subsamples of the 5,914 children who were born in Pelotas in 1982 over the last 30 years.

Tags:

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil's Butantan Institute is manufacturing a coronavirus vaccine in partnership with the Chinese company Sinovac | Rafael Henrique/SOPA Images/SIPA USA/PA Images

The Day Funk Music Came to the Rescue of the Covid Vaccination Program in Brazil

For almost three decades, Brazil’s baile funk music genre has been attacked by conservative ...

A nurse wearing a mask

Brazil Was Ready for Bad Weather. With Coronavirus It Got the Perfect Storm

April would have been a busy month for Brazilian hospitals anyway. As the population ...

An indigenous community in Brazil wearing masks against coronavirus

With Close to 1,000 Deaths, Brazil Indians Get an App to Keep Track of Covid-19

Indigenous and environmental organizations in Brazil launched an app aimed at alerting indigenous communities ...

This Holiday Season, Get a Flu Shot and Give the Gift of Health to Your Family

Advertorial When you get a flu shot this holiday season, you’re not only decreasing ...

Brazilians Can Dial 192 and Get Emergency Care in 10 Minutes

At the inauguration of the Mobile Emergency Care Service (Samu, Serviço de Atendimento Móvel ...

Labiaplasty in Brazil has never been more popular

Despite Economic Crisis, Demand for Designer Vaginas in Brazil Grows by 80%

In Brazil, a country famed for its obsession with the beautiful body, women are ...

In Brazil, Diplomas Don’t Open Doors for Women

Gender equality in Brazilian science is increasing up to doctorate level but few women ...

Jair Bolsonaro and Narendra Modi shake hands at a 2020 meeting

How the Populist Leaders of Brazil and India Made Their Countries World Champions of Covid

India recently pushed Brazil out of the media spotlight with its surge in coronavirus ...

Sign in Curitiba, Brazil, bus says: "Wear a mask."

How a High-contact Culture Like Brazil Is Coping in a Covid World

Christmas is coming. Like many people around the world, Brazilians envy North Americans for ...