Protesters took to the streets across Brazil on Saturday to demand President Jair Bolsonaro’s resignation over his response to the pandemic.
The Brazilian government has come under increasing pressure for its Covid-19 policies, with the country experiencing one of the world’s worst outbreaks.
The protests also took place as Brazil logged more than 500,000 coronavirus deaths, the second-highest global death toll after the United States.
What Happened at the Protests?
Thousands of people protested in the capital, Brasília, as well as 43 other cities. Demonstrators chanted and beat drums, demanding more economic support and vaccines.
“We are protesting against the genocidal Bolsonaro government that did not buy vaccines and has done nothing to take care of its people in the last year,” Aline Rabelo, a 36-year-old protesting in Brasília, told Reuters news agency.
While thousands turned out across the country for the demonstrations, attendance appeared to be lower than the mass protests held at the end of May.
How Has Bolsonaro Responded to the Crisis?
Bolsonaro has been widely criticized for not taking up early offers to buy coronavirus vaccines. To date, only 11% of Brazil’s population is fully vaccinated while 29% have received a first dose, according to the Health Ministry.
The Brazilian president — who fell ill with the coronavirus in July last year — has also downplayed the severity of the pandemic from the start and opposed lockdown measures on economic grounds.
Most recently, he voiced doubt over the ability of coronavirus vaccines to combat the pandemic.
A special parliamentary committee is currently investigating the Bolsonaro administration’s management of the pandemic.
Half a Million Deaths
The country, which never had the pandemic under control, has hit the tragic milestone as the virus continues to rage and President Jair Bolsonaro refuses to follow scientific recommendations.
Brazil hit the tragic milestone of half a million Covid deaths on Saturday when it added 2,495 fatalities to its count.
The country has the second highest pandemic death toll in the world, second only to the United States, with its 600,000 deaths — though the US population is also 55% larger.
And unlike Americans, whose death and infection numbers have plummeted after a major vaccination campaign, Brazilians are now going through their second highest level of daily cases and deaths — only the peak in March and April was higher. In most states, case numbers are remaining stable or increasing.
The infection rate has been accelerating since early May after governors and mayors relaxed social distancing measures, a move that experts now blame for the current spike.
Brazil’s pandemic situation is currently “extremely delicate,” according to epidemiologist Carolina Coutinho, who researches at the Getúlio Vargas Foundation.
It’s the highly transmissible coronavirus variants, which are more likely to infect or reinfect people, that are making the pandemic so difficult to control.
A study by the government’s Butantan Institute found that, in São Paulo state, the gamma variant (or P.1, originally found in Manaus) made up the vast majority of infections, as of May 29. The alpha variant from the UK and the beta variant from South Africa each represented less than 5% of cases.
The delta variant has not been identified in Brazil yet. But on a national level, the country is ill-equipped to sequence genomes and identify new variants, said Coutinho.
An Anti-science President
As a backdrop to the health emergency, Brazilians have also been following a Senate commission that has been investigating the government’s handling of the Covid crisis since early May. The commission has invited several ministers and government aides to testify as well as provide information, which the press has been covering since last year.
It has revealed that President Jair Bolsonaro prevented his health ministers from following scientific recommendations, promoted drugs that were proven to be ineffective against Covid-19, feuded with governors and mayors that defended social isolation measures and refused several vaccine offers.
In mid-2020, for example, the Health Ministry rejected Pfizer’s offer of 70 million vaccine doses as well as Butantan Institute’s offer of 60 million doses.
As the pandemic worsened early this year, Bolsonaro struck new deals to buy vaccines and is now asking for the doses that he rejected in 2020 to be delivered more quickly. In early June, he promised that every Brazilian who wants to get vaccinated will be able to get jabbed by the end of the year.
Meanwhile, he has continued to criticize physical distancing measures, questioning whether face masks work and pushing conspiracy theories.
In his weekly Facebook Live post on Thursday, Bolsonaro said masks reduce the amount of oxygen you take in, which is false. Last week, he proposed that people who have been vaccinated or have recovered from Covid should stop wearing masks. Specialists have said it is “absurd” and “reckless” to stop wearing masks at this point in the pandemic.
Vaccines Are Hard to Come by
Brazil’s universal health care system SUS, one of the largest in the world, has a track record of successful vaccination campaigns.
But the government’s refusal to order vaccines last year and difficulties importing an active pharmaceutical ingredient needed for the CoronaVac and AstraZeneca vaccines have prevented the country from planning a vaccination drive that would match SUS capabilities.
Epidemiologists and data scientists have said Brazil would need to inoculate about 2 million people per day, but as the rollout remains sluggish and infection numbers remain high, the virus is currently winning the race.
Since April, Brazil has administered between 599,000 and 730,000 vaccine doses per day. Only on Thursday did the country surpass its 2-million dose goal, vaccinating 2.2 million people.
Brazil has fully vaccinated a little over 11% of its 211 million population, compared to around 45% in the US and 30% in Germany; experts estimate that 80% is needed to reach herd immunity. Until then, countries will have to keep up measures like continuous testing, wearing face masks and enforcing restrictions on crowds.
Underreporting Hides a Greater Tragedy
Brazil actually exceeded 500,000 deaths some months ago, according to biologist Marcelo Bragatte, one of the coordinators of the Covid-19 Analysis Network in the Federal University of Rio Grande.
The country probably has around 600,000 Covid deaths already, but has been underreporting them, he said.
Bragatte’s projection takes into account excess deaths due to severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) since the beginning of the pandemic, comparing the numbers with data from the last years.
“There are many cases in which the person dies that it is not confirmed that it was Covid, and they are registered as a SARS case,” said Bragatte.
This estimate would put Brazil on the same level as the US, which currently has the highest pandemic death toll.
Bragatte also projects that Brazil will continue to hit high infection and death numbers if the vaccine rollout doesn’t speed up. The numbers will only improve if Brazilians stick to recommended protocols like wearing a mask, physical distancing and avoiding meeting people indoors, he said.
“Since the government isn’t implementing the health measures, the responsibility falls on each citizen to do what they can,” he said.
The problem is that it’s not only the spread of the virus that won’t slow down.
“The misinformation in this country is not going away. It’s at a plateau. And because of that, people’s actions aren’t improving,” said Bragatte.
DW