Brazilian President Wants to Jail Journalists Who Use Wiretaps

Veja magazine cover The IAPA (Inter American Press Association) is voicing concern at a bill introduced to congress by Brazil's executive branch that would amend the rules regulating wiretaps and make it an offense punishable with imprisonment for journalists and news media executives to divulge information obtained from wiretaps without a judge's authorization.

The chairman of the IAPA's Committee on Freedom of the Press and Information, Gonzalo Marroquí­n, offered support for the arguments made by Brazil's National Association of Newspapers (ANJ) criticizing the bill introduced by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's government.

The new law would set ground rules for unlawful wiretaps, a move that the organization said "directly affects freedom of the press and amounts to nothing less than an authoritarian and undemocratic proposal."

Marroquí­n, editor of the Guatemala City, Guatemala, newspaper Prensa Libre, explained, "This amendment, apart from penalizing the unlawful conduct of government officials engaged in telephone wiretapping, at the same time unfairly places the blame on journalists for divulging information that may have been leaked to them and which could be of public interest. In consequence, what is really jeopardized is the people's right to be informed."

The proposed law, currently under debate in the Chamber of Deputies (lower house of Congress), would make it a criminal offense for individual journalists, the press and their news sources to divulge either lawful or unlawful phone taps without court authorization.

The project amends Article 15 of the Penal Code, increasing the prison term from three to five years and imposing fines on anyone who "directly or through third parties" carries out telephone wiretapping "for purposes other than those foreseen under the law."

Penalties are increased 50% when a public official is involved. Final passage of the bill would amend Law 9,296/06 which regulates electronic surveillance.

The issue of clandestine recording of phone conversations originated with complaints about wiretaps on politicians and members of the Federal Supreme Court. The most recent incident was the recording of a phone conversation on July 15 between Supreme Court Chief Justice Gilmar Mendes and opposition Senator Demóstenes Torres, published in the magazine Veja a month later.

The magazine said the information had been provided by an anonymous source belonging to the Brazilian Intelligence Agency (ABIN), an agency of the Executive branch.

Just who might have ordered the wiretap has sparked an internal debate within the federal government involving official departments, cabinet ministers and members of the judicial and legislative branches. In October 2007, Brazil's Chamber of Deputies set up a Parliamentary Investigative Commission to look into the issue.

Tags:

You May Also Like

IMF Wants More from Brazil

Every Brazilian had to work one whole month in 2002 just to pay Brazil’s ...

Brazil Approves Release of Monsanto’s Transgenic Corn Under Protests

Brazil's National Biosafety Technical Committee (CTNBio) approved this Thursday, August 16, the commercial release ...

Ready for War: Brazil Buys 250 German Tanks, French Fighters Coming Soon

Brazil has just purchased 250 German Leopard 1 A5 tanks, which will be used ...

Brazil’s Petrobras Has Big Plans to Take on the World

Brazilian oil giant Petrobras expands investments and seeks joint venture in the US. Nestor ...

Brazil’s Speaker of the House Bribery Case Goes to the Supreme

Brazil’s Federal Police commissioner Sérgio Menezes affirmed that there is already sufficient evidence that ...

Inflation Fears Bring Market Down in Brazil

Brazilian stocks fell, yesterday, alongside lackluster trading in the U.S. Brazilian equities suffered as ...

Brazil’s Lula Calls Blair and Again Proposes Summit of G-8 and G-20

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, on Tuesday, January 31, telephoned the Prime ...

Brazil’s Embraer Has Slight Slowdown in Delivery Pace

Brazilian aircraft maker Embraer closed out the first quarter of 2010 (1Q10) having delivered ...

Brazil and US Join Forces to Fight Terror and Piracy

Brazil and the United States will be able to expedite actions to prevent, investigate, ...

Brazilian Court’s Latest Decision: Amazon’s Belo Monte Dam Is Off

In the latest chapter of a decades-long dramatic battle between environmentalists and the government ...