Before this decision, only 7,061 ha had been demarcated and another 11,009 ha had not, and continued being invaded by the eucalyptus and cellulose producing multinational company Aracruz Celulose. By means of this decision, the Brazilian government fulfilled the Brazilian constitution that says that it is the responsibility of the government to demarcate lands, traditionally occupied by indigenous peoples and necessary for their physical and cultural survival.
The victory has been and continues being celebrated by all the seven Tupinikim and Guarani villages. The chiefs declared that this victory is both a result from their union, their courage and determination to struggle for the lands they were evicted from in the past, guaranteeing the future of their children, but at the same time, this victory was also possible because of a strong network of support, both in Brazil as well as outside Brazil.
Some remarks about this decision by Indian leaders and their friends:
– Within a government full of contradictions, the Minister of Justice definitely showed courage by taking this decision, while receiving an enormous pressure of members of parliament and senate, governor of Espírito Santo and all the actors in the agribusiness sector, besides of the regional and national media.
– This is definitely the most important decision in the whole demarcation procedure. What is left now is (1)Â the physical demarcation (in the field) of the 18,070 hectares, (2) the homologation (recognition) of this physical demarcation by the President of the Republic (comparing this work with the ministerial decrees), and then (3) registration in the local register's office.
– The next urgent step, according to the minister, will be the signing of an agreement between Indians, Aracruz and the government through which it will be settled how to deal with the compensation for the Aracruz company for being forced to leave the area of the 11,009 ha. This agreement certainly will consider the wood inside the 11,009 hectares as part of this negotiation, once the government has declared several times that it has no money to 'compensate' the company (although the pulp and tree plantation sector has US$ 8.7 billion guaranteed in public loans until 2010.)Â
Although the Indians blame Aracruz for destroying the forest that they used in the past, this agreement is important for both the government and the Indians in order to prevent a long judicial battle from the Aracruz side that could paralyze the regularization of the lands.
The Tupinikim and Guarani already started meetings among the chiefs and leaders to be prepared for this negotiation and they also will organize a general assembly of the communities.
– This decision of the government means that the Brazilian government definitely does not recognize the studies presented by Aracruz, and published broadly in popular folders in the region and the country and even outside the country, that the Tupinikim indigenous peoples never inhabited the region of Aracruz.
This study is supposedly produced by 15 'specialists' whose names Aracruz still hasn't published. The publication of this study, together with allegations that especially the Tupinikim Indians are no Indians, lead to a condemnation of Aracruz by the Federal Court in Linhares, Espírito Santo, for discriminatory behavior, in December, 2006.