Brazilian Tragedy: Flight Controller Noticed Foul Up But Couldn’t Undo It

    Disgruntled with their working conditions and the slow pace of reforms, air traffic controllers in Brazil continue to vent their insatisfaction and shed light on the worst Brazilian air tragedy ever in candid talks to reporters during anonymous interviews.

    The last revelation comes from a veteran flight controller in Brazilian capital Brasí­lia who talked to the Federal District’s main daily, the Correio Braziliense.

    According to this account, when a more experienced controller – he has been working for over five years in Brasí­lia – took over from a beginner worker he immediately noticed there was something wrong with the Legacy executive jet piloted by two Americans.

    The small plane was on the same 37,000 feet route of the Boeing 737 coming from the opposite direction. And he immediately started a frantic effort to avoid what he saw was an imminent tragedy.

    "He wanted to undo the foul up, trying to contact the jet to find out the altitude the plane was flying, but he was not able to establish communication," said the controller, who has been in the job over 25 years. According to him, his colleague has been feeling "disoriented" since the accident, which killed 154.

    He wouldn’t reveal, however, the age of the younger and inexperienced professional, who seems to have mistakenly assumed that the Legacy was in a different altitude. It’s known that the youngest of the 13 controllers who are being investigated in connection with the accident is 27 years old.

    At Cindacta 1 (the Brasí­lia Air Control Tower), says the Correio, controllers admit that they have made a mistake, but according to one of the professionals there the oversight by the unskilled controller may also be explained by excessive work: "My God, he was monitoring 22 planes," he stated. 

    During a Senate hearing, Air Force commander brigadier Luiz Carlos Bueno, told senators that the controller in charge of the Legacy was monitoring only 5 planes when the collision occurred. He didn’t mention, however, how many planes were being overseen by the previous professional at the tower.

    The young operator who erred had gone through a short four-months internship. Controllers like him, who monitor planes in a 500-mile radius, normally train double the time before they are allowed to become a full-fledged professional.

    But the use of untrained controllers hasn’t been that rare in Brazil these days. And they apparently continue to be integrated in the service. Another controller reported that he saw a discussion between a Cindacta 1 supervisor and the control center’s new chief, colonel Carlos Aquino:

    "The controller, who was being transferred from another Cindacta, had just arrived that same day. And the commander already wanted to put him on the job. They are qualifying people who are not prepared and then throwing them in the fire."

    Hiring New Controllers 
       
    Brazil’s Diário Oficial (Federal Daily Gazette) is publishing today the rules for those interested in working as air traffic controllers. The military, which are in charge of flight control in the country, have 160 openings for the position.

    Candidates need to have finished high school and well as knowledge of computer and English language. Registration can be completed online from December 5 to December 15. There will be several scholastic as well as medical and psychological tests.

    Training starts February 26 and will last one year. To get the position candidates will have to become Air Force sergeants. Average salary for an air controller is 1,600 reais (US$ 740) a month.

    Registration won’t be an easy task. According to the instructions posted on the Internet for those interested in applying for a chance to become an air traffic controller the conditions are:

    a) to be Brazilian;

    b) to be volunteer;

    c) to be at least 1.55 m tall if a female and at least 1.60 m. if a male;

    d) to be within the age limit contemplated in item 2 of the appendix to these instructions;

    e) to be single;

    f) if younger than 18 to be expressly authorized by the legal responsible person;

    g) to be up-to-date with your electoral obligations;

    h) to not have criminal records regarding offenses of fraudulent nature;

    i) if female, to agree with the requirement regarding impediment to getting pregnant in the period between the registration to the admission exam and the course conclusion;

    j) to not possess Certificate of Military Service Exemption due to
    physical, mental or moral inability;

    k) if male to be up-to-date with the Military Service;

    l) to not have been, previously, excluded from the active military service due to bad behavior,  lack of moral integrity or for incompatibility with the military career, or dismissed from course or course administered in a military teaching establishment for the same reasons;

    m) to not be performing the Initial Military Service at registration time;

    n) if on active military service, to be classified, at least, as having "Good Behavior";

    o) if on active or reserve military service, to have ranking lower than a Third Sergeant

    p) if a military,  include, in the Registration Request Form, the information on your Commander, Chief or Director regarding the conditions contemplated in paragraphs "d", "h", "l", "m", "n" and "o" of this item;

    q) to have concluded or be in conditions to conclude high school , with good performance: 

    r) to pay the registration fee and prove that it has been paid; and

    s) to register using the proper Registration Request Form.

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (7)

    • Englishman in Sao Paulo

      Re: Loony Tunes
      Well said! Where is the seemingly essential requirement for English skills?
      I’ve worked in Brazil for over ten years and my conclusion is that, on the whole, Brazilians couldn’t organise a piss up in a brewery if they were given diagrams. TheyÀ¢€™re just a bloody shower.

    • Rick

      You nailed it, Will, “disqualifying”…..also the Brazilian system for training pilots at all levels is basically the same as during WWII. It is freely admitted that the system serves to discourage/disqualify the majority who wish to learn to fly, since there are not enough positions available even for those who do get their tickets.

      A few years ago at the end of a war in Angola, pilots from that country flooded into Brazil and took most of the available flying jobs away from Brazilians, since foreigners canÀ‚´t get commercial or ATP tickets here, EXCEPT for those having Portuguese passports. So in various aviation career areas, prohibiting foreigners and making it difficult even for nationals seems, note I said “seems”, to be a matter of policy.

    • Will Pickering

      Look at this requirement:
      “s) to register using the proper Registration Request Form. “

      This is typical requirement in Brazilian bureaucratice instructions, and it strikes me as bizzare – if you don’t have the form, how can you register? Maybe some sleazebags occasionally try convince a bureaucrat to put them on a job list without their having filled out the form (perhaps the person is too lazy to do it, or is illiterate, or is late for the deadline, or is a relative of other bureacrat, who knows?). Then this rule would be a way of automatically disqualifying such people.

    • Simpleton

      Not Brazilian, not single, probably not within the age bracket. Who do I have to bribe to get an exception?

    • hmm

      Loony tunes…
      a) to be Brazilian;

      b) to be volunteer;

      c) to be at least 1.55 m tall if a female and at least 1.60 m. if a male;

      d) to be within the age limit contemplated in item 2 of the appendix to these instructions;

      e) to a be a bachelor;

      f) if younger than 18 to be expressly authorized by the legal responsible person;

      g) to be up-to-date with your electoral obligations;

      h) to not have criminal records regarding offenses of fraudulent nature;

      i) if female, to agree with the requirement regarding impediment to getting pregnant in the period between the registration to the admission exam and the course conclusion;

      j) to not possess Certificate of Military Service Exemption due to
      physical, mental or moral inability;

      k) if male to be up-to-date with the Military Service;

      l) to not have been, previously, excluded from the active military service due to bad behavior, lack of moral integrity or for incompatibility with the military career, or dismissed from course or course administered in a military teaching establishment for the same reasons;

      m) to not be performing the Initial Military Service at registration time;

      n) if on active military service, to be classified, at least, as having “Good Behavior”;

      o) if on active or reserve military service, to have ranking lower than a Third Sergeant

      p) if a military, include, in the Registration Request Form, the information on your Commander, Chief or Director regarding the conditions contemplated in paragraphs “d”, “h”, “l”, “m”, “n” and “o” of this item;

      q) to have concluded or be in conditions to conclude high school , with good performance:

      r) to pay the registration fee and prove that it has been paid; and

      s) to register using the proper Registration Request Form.

      These points just prove how bizarre and loony the system is. The Brazilian mind is simply not wired correctly, and because of this you get surreal requirements such as the above.

      And donˢ۪t forget, you have to PAY to apply.

      Ya, Brazil Рthe country of the future. Good grief. on a final note, one of the many possible explanations about the cause of the flight 1907 accident was a miscommunication between the American Pilots and ATC. English is the international language used for ATC involving foreign aircraft. Does anyone see anywhere in that list a requirement for English skills? But, they do stress the importance of being a bachelor! Wouldnˢ۪t wonˢ۪t the nagging wench calling your employee at work now would we, guv!

    • Robert

      wheres the apology
      where is the apology from the brazilian government for blaming the crash on the gringo americans??

    • alltheway

      I know this has nothing to do with the accident but why is “e) be a bachelor)” a requirement to be trained to be a controller ? and I don’t see a similar requirement for women to be single ..

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Brian Smith, president of Coca-Cola of Brazil with the Brazilian line of products

    Coca-Cola Is Betting on Brazil’s Thirst

    When the political crisis in Brazil first gave signs that it would be around ...

    Cicex Wants to Be Brazil Exporter’s Right Hand

    The Brazilian Minister of Development, Industry and Foreign Trade, Luiz Fernando Furlan, inaugurated yesterday ...

    Led by Brazil Mercosur’s Exports Grow 20% and Imports 18%

    Imports of goods by Africa and the Middle East grew 18% in nominal terms ...

    Crowd Pleaser

    Paulo Coelho is today the best-known Brazilian author, with more than 21 million books ...

    Bus set on fire by organized crime in São Paulo, Brazil

    Enough Already of Pretending Brazil Doesn’t Need a Revolution

    Enough already of all the cruelty. Of bus passengers burned alive, of young people ...

    Jewish Leader in Brazil Accuses Israel of Doing Dirty Work in Lebanon

    The president of the Israelite Confederation in Brazil, rabbi Henry Sobel, informed that the ...

    Brazil Strategy Network

    US-Brazil Group to Focus on Civil Society in National Meeting in NY

    The Brazil Strategy Network (BSN) will hold its fourth annual National Meeting on Saturday, ...

    Brazilian Sebastií£o Salgado Pans ‘Greediness of Soybean Culture’

    The Brazilian world-renowned photographer Sebastião Salgado was an illustrious guest at the Kuarup (an ...

    Brazilian gets vaccine against yellow fever

    In Brazil, Yellow Fever Scare Brings Fear of an Epidemic

    Brazil's Health Minister, José Gomes Temporão, used a radio and TV pool this Sunday, ...

    Brazilian honey

    Despite EU Embargo Brazil Honey Export Grows Slightly

    Brazilian honey exports continue to grow in the accumulated result for the year. Despite ...