US Pilots and ExcelAire Sued in New York for Brazilian Air Tragedy

    Another American law firm, this time, Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, announced they are filing a lawsuit today against ExcelAire and Honeywell International, in a New York federal court.

    The US lawyers are representing family members of ten passengers on Gol Airlines Flight 1907 who were killed after the aircraft collided with an aircraft owned and operated by ExcelAire. Honeywell is the manufacturer of the Traffic Alert and Collision Avoidance System (TCAS), a device that should have avoided such a crash.

    One hundred and forty eight passengers and six crew members died on September 29, 2006, when the Gol Airlines aircraft plunged nose-first into the Amazon rainforest after colliding with the ExcelAire aircraft. The lawsuit seeks compensatory and punitive damages against ExcelAire and Honeywell for their negligence.

    "Although official investigations of the Gol Airlines tragedy are ongoing, sufficient evidence presently exists to allege that negligence by ExcelAire and Honeywell were substantial factors contributing to the fatal collision," stated Robert L. Lieff, founding partner of Lieff Cabraser.

    Brazilian attorney Leonardo Amarante, whose law firm is working in partnership with Lieff Cabraser, commented, "The families of this horrible tragedy are asserting their rights under United States law against ExcelAire and Honeywell to ensure that all facts surrounding the accident are uncovered and that such a disaster is never repeated."

    Nigel Taylor, an attorney with Lieff Cabraser based in London and one of the most experienced aviation law attorneys in the world, according to the law firm, stated, "This lawsuit holds out great hope for the victims’ families to hold all responsible parties accountable and obtain fair compensation. We have assembled a top notch, global team of attorneys and aviation experts to prosecute the case."

    Hans-Peter Graf, a veteran commercial pilot and former investigator in charge at the Swiss Aircraft Accidents Investigation Bureau who specializes in flight operation and human factors, has been retained by Lieff Cabraser to work on the case.

    The complaint charges that the pilots of the ExcelAire jet were flying at an incorrect altitude at the time of the collision, failed to operate the jet’s transponder and radio equipment properly, and failed to maintain communication with Brazilian air traffic control in violation of international civil aviation standards. If the pilots of the ExcelAire aircraft had followed these standards, the collision would not have occurred.

    At the time of the collision, the ExcelAire aircraft’s transponder was not functioning. A transponder is the component part that transmits a plane’s altitude and operates its automatic anti-collision system.

    Honeywell shares responsibility for the tragedy, the complaint alleges, because it defectively designed the transponder on the ExcelAire jet, and failed to warn of dangers resulting from foreseeable uses of the transponder.

    On Tuesday, November 7, 2006, at 11 am, Robert L. Lieff and Lexi Hazam will hold a press conference, in Brazilian capital Brasí­lia, on the filing of the lawsuit, discuss their investigation of the Gol Airlines Flight 1907 accident and explain the grounds for the liability of ExcelAire and Honeywell.

    Family members of victims of the tragedy will participate in addition to Leonardo Amarante and Hans-Peter Graf.

    Lieff Cabraser is among the largest law firms in the United States that represents exclusively plaintiffs, and has been recognized by the prestigious National Law Journal for the last four consecutive years as one of the top plaintiffs’ law firms in America.

    Only two other law firms in the United States have received this honor for the last four years. Lieff Cabraser is the only firm recognized that practices aviation law.

    The firm currently represents aviation accident victims in connection with, among others, the crash of a Helios plane in Greece in August, 2005, the crash of a China Eastern plane in November 2004 near Bautou, China, the crash of a Flash Air plane near Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt in January, 2004, the crash of an Air Algerie plane in Tamanrasset in March 2003, the crash of a Mandala plane near Medan, Indonesia in September 2005, the crash of a West Caribbean Airways plane in Venezuela in August 2005, and the crash of a Comair Airlines jet in Lexington, Kentucky in August 2006.

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (4)

    • forrest allen brown

      So what about the ATC they are all brasilian
      So now all the ATC are to ill to talk to the police ?
      so how much money will the make by sueing a US firm insted trying to sue GOL and or the ATC from brasil .

      brasilians quick to jump on the money wagon

      ALL ABOUT THE MONEY

    • ch.c.

      curious again…….
      that the headline says : US Pilots and ExcelAire Sued ……

      and that during the whole article, it says that those sued are Honeywell and
      ExcelAir !!!!! but not a word on the US pilots being sued !

      Great….these Brazilians Reporters ! Just worth 1 centavos….your articles.
      I suppose this is the reason they are published on this site and not in a known Brazilian
      Newspapers or Magazine !

      And this demonstrate that neither Amorim, Pires or other brazilian officials had to accuse openly the US pilots first…..even before the end of the investigations !!!!!!

      Brazilians are really fool and crazy !

    • Observer

      Well now we do have the worst part of the US entering Brazil. By their own press release they are ambulance chasers of the worst order. Their complaint as information that has already been discredited – but they are lawyers -nothing better should be expected. As far as ATCS, I believe you need to have a unit funcitoning in both planes inorder for the system to work as they communicate with each other. So IF in fact the transponder was defective on the ExcelAire plane – then the ATCS system would not work for any plane nor ATC- seemingly a single point of failure – which should make someone think of duplicating this vital piece of backup safety equipment. I say backup as with proper air traffic control instructions, no one would have two planes in the same location at the same altitude – ATCS is just a backup not the primary failure. The primary failure to my understanding was the ATC direction to the ExcelAire flight to maintain 37,000 ft to Manaus when the Gol jet was on a identical course in the opposite direction.

    • Stephen

      Stinks
      What about the automatic anti-collision system on the GOL aircraft? Was it working and if so should it not of sounded the alarm to the GOL pilots. No one speaks about this issue! Why is it a onesided error when each aircraft is protected from a mid air crash? Stinky business.

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Brazil Charged with Human Rights Violations in Washington, DC

    The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, of the Organization of American States (OAS), held ...

    Superior Tribunal de Justiça in Brasília

    Outrage After Brazil’s Superior Court Rules Sex with Three 12-year-old Girls Was Not Rape

    A panel of judges at Brazil’s Superior Appellate Court (Superior Tribunal de Justiça – ...

    Itaipu dam shared by Brazil and Paraguay

    Energy War: Brazil Threatens to Stop All Investment in Paraguay

    Paraguay and Brazil are preparing for a long dispute over prices from energy generated ...

    Brazil Selic

    It’s 13.75%: For Fourth Time in a Row Brazil Raises Key Interest Rate

    Brazil's Copom (Monetary Policy Committee) of the Brazilian Central Bank (BC) raised Brazil's base ...

    Lula on Dilma's body

    Dilma Running for Brazil’s Presidency as National Candidate Against São Paulo

    Brazil’s nationwide elections on October, 3 will see more than 130 million voters choose ...

    Pirelli Spends Over US$ 50 Million on New Brazilian Unit

    Italy-based tire company Pirelli inaugurated Wednesday, March 22, the expansion of the company industrial ...

    Presidents Hu and Medvedev

    Brazil Hosting Chinese and Russian Presidents Next Week

    Hu Jintao, the president of China, will be visiting Brazil, Venezuela and Chile in ...

    Pizza

    Brazilian Restaurateur in San Francisco Can Get 5 Years for Hiring Illegals

    Glenio Silva, the owner of two northern California Bay Area pizza restaurants, has been ...

    Brazil’s Plans to Keep Young Farmers in the Country

    Brazil has 6 million young people, 18-24 years old, working in the countryside. 1.8 ...