IMF Lauds Brazil But Also Urges Budgetary Reform

    IMF’s managing director Rodrigo de Rato, during a press conference in Singapore, Friday, September 15, praised Brazil for setting a good example in Latin America on how to deal with social spending. Rato also said that Brazil needs a budgetary modernization.

    A reporter introduced the theme Brazil by asking Rato to comment on the fact that Brazil is complaining about the way the IMF intends to conduct their quota reform and also about Paris Club spending in the country.

    "What I have to say is that I believe, not only in the specific interest of Brazil, but in the interest of all of Latin America, to have a change in the Fund and we make the Fund more responsive to emerging economies and low-income countries. I don’t have any doubt about that.

    "And my very frequent interchanges of views with Latin American representatives and members of governments, and Brazilian ones in particular, make me believe that is a shared view. I think that we are moving and that is the best thing the institution can do.

    "We are moving in making more dynamic economies have a more important role to play in the institution, and many of those, more dynamic economies are emerging economies. And we are also moving into a very important, new dimension of recognizing low-income countries’ voices.

    "I don’t have any doubt that view is shared by the Brazilian authorities and of course then we will have to discuss issues very concretely. I understand that is not easy for countries to agree to, for instance, a new formula, but certainly as the agreement of the Board recognizes, GDP should play a significant important role in that new formula, together with other components besides GDP.

    "And that, of course, I think that is also a very important question that should be reflected by governments like Brazil when they make their decisions.

    "On Brazil’s economic policies, certainly first of all, social spending, I would say, independently of the actual figures, Brazil has made very important steps in making social spending more effective, and poverty reduction in Brazil in the recent years has been moving forward.

    "It is a good example in Latin America, not the only one, but a good example of changes in the way of targeting social spending for the better. So, in that respect, I want to say that I am encouraged by what has been learned.

    "At the same time, I think that the effort that Brazil has made in reducing public debt is increasingly important, and there are challenges there, of course, there are challenges of keeping a high level of primary surplus and at the same time addressing social needs and infrastructural needs.

    "As I have said on occasion that in Brazil, I want to repeat it now, one of the big challenges of Brazil’s budgetary policy is rigidity. We believe Brazil needs a more flexible budgetary framework in which less expenditures are preconceived in terms of assigning already the revenue. That is a key element in the modernization of the budgetary framework in Brazil.

    "I also want to thank the Brazilian authorities by the work we have done together in exploring the role of private capital in contributing to infrastructure, and I think that some of the experiences in Brazil, but also in Chile and in South Africa can be very useful for many emerging economies."

    John Lipsky, IMF First Deputy Managing Director, added to Rato’s comment by saying: "I want to add one point. Our basic outlook for the Brazilian economy is a positive one. We’re looking for somewhat faster growth next year, about 4 percent growth in Brazil; so the context for these policy opportunities is going to be a positive and benign one, and our hope is that in this relatively benign environment that the authorities will be able to continue the progress in regard to spending that the Managing Director just discussed."

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (1)

    • ch.c.

      As per Bloomberg News, September 15, ……here is what apparently De Rato of the IMF said :

      -” Brazil has run annual deficits for more than five decades because the law forces the government to spend about $9 in every $10 of the budget on wages, pensions, education and health allowances. Last year, half the federal budget went to pay for salaries and pensions for 2 million government workers, while less than 5 percent was funneled into new investment, according to Budget and Planning Ministry figures “

      – “Brazil is the most indebted emerging- market nation with more than $450 billion in liabilities. The size of its national debt is 49 percent of gross domestic product, above the 30 percent of GDP average for a country with BBB ratings”

      – ” In Brazil, a country of 180 million, two in every five citizens earn less than $2 a day”

      Quite different from what the article above is writing !

      Where is the truth on what De Rato said or did not say ?????

      I also just remind you that Brazil has the World Highest Poverty Rate……when compared to their GDP per capita.
      And that Brazil had/has/will have the lowest economic growth of ALL developing countries, of MOST poorest countries. And this gold medal is good since Lula has been elected.

      Giving compliments to these official stats…..dont augur well.

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Brazil and Argentina Unite to Counter US Soy Prices

    Joint soy production between Brazil and Argentina is greater than that produced by the ...

    In Brazil See-Saw Is Up While Lula Ponders Whether to Run Again

    Latin American markets strongly recovered from weakness yesterday, on a Brazilian rally. Political tensions ...

    Tax Revenue in February Reaches Record High in Brazil

    The deputy secretary of the Brazilian IRS (Receita Federal), Ricardo Pinheiro, says that record ...

    Brazilian prisoners

    With World’s Fourth Prison Population, Brazil Is Denounced by the UN

    Overpopulated cells, little access to the Justice system, the indiscriminate use of provisional premises, ...

    Dengue and TB: A Two-Front Battle in Brazil

    Brazil government’s actions to control dengue resulted in a 73.3% reduction in the incidence ...

    Bureaucracy in Brazil

    Brazil Entrepreneurs Ask For Less Red Tape and Flexible Labor Laws

    Brazilian entrepreneurs participating in a meeting, last week, with the presidential candidates, organized by ...

    Brazil Sets Up Wide Monitoring System to Prevent Bird Flu

    The Brazilian Ministries of Agriculture and Environment set up a plan to monitor birds ...

    Brazil: Seeing Dollar Signs

    Brazilian banks are betting in a growing economy for 2004. At the same time, ...

    Brazil’s Central Bank Workers Go Back on Strike Tuesday

    The two-day strike of Brazil’s Central Bank employees ended, Thursday, August 25, but will ...

    Brazil’s Petrobras Has Big Plans to Take on the World

    Brazilian oil giant Petrobras expands investments and seeks joint venture in the US. Nestor ...