The Tough Questions Brazil’s Lula Refused to Answer

    With an advantage in the polls that seems insurmountable, being the numbers so expressive that would guarantee his reelection in the first round of Brazil’s October 1st election, Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has been refusing to participate in television debates with the other presidential candidates.

    He also has turned down invitations to be interviewed by Brazil’s leading dailies. O Estado de S. Paulo, Folha de S. Paulo and Rio’s most prestigious newspaper, O Globo, have submitted questions to the presidential candidates and published them in recent days, but Lula has said no to all the invitations.

    Now, O Globo, in an unheard gesture by the Brazilian press, decided to make public the questions it had prepared to ask the president leaving a blank space after each of them for the answers that never came.

    Ironically, just earlier in the week, the Brazilian president had extolled peoples right to information during the Newspapers National Association congress.

    Under the headline "Far from the ‘public square of debates,’" using a president’s quote, O Globo dedicated the whole page 13 to Lula’s non-answers.

    Among the interviewers were writers Luiz Fernando Verí­ssimo, João Ubaldo Ribeiro and Paulo Coelho. O Globo also cited a Lula’s old interview: "My political history owes much to the free and independent press."

    Some of the non-answered questions:

    "In September of 2002, you, as a candidate, criticized the president Fernando Henrique Cardoso, who, in eight years, had only met twice with the governors to discuss the states debt, and never to discuss themes such as violence. You also defended the idea that the federal government should coordinate the national battle against narcotraffic and organized crime. Don’t you think that president Lula should have listened to what candidate Lula had to say?" 

    "Once, during the worst times of the mensalão (big monthly allowance) crisis, you said that you had been betrayed. (…) After all, were you betrayed or not? And by who?"

    "When, you recently said, in a meeting with intellectuals in São Paulo, that politics is done with whoever we got and not with whom we want, were you agreeing with the artists that, in Rio, admitted that politics is done with your hands deep in shit, and more than this, would you admit that real politics led you to use schemes like the mensalão to organize your majority in Congress?"

    "As good as the international economic situation is, and as good as the numbers of the Brazilian economy are today, the country’s growth continues as mediocre as in the preceding government that you criticize so much. Proportionally, your results are even worse, due to the conditions of the international economy, without crises, and with the world growing at much higher rates than Brazil. What is going wrong?"

    Verí­ssimo had prepared the question: "You ended up having a government more social-democrat than expected. Should we expect in your second mandate a Lula still more to the center looking for consensus or more to the left?" 

    Economy reporter, Miriam Leitão has this to ask: "You told me in an interview in 2002 the following: ‘Miriam, I’m going to tell you something because I want you to check back on this with me. I’m going to do an agrarian reform without any occupation and without any death.’ Heeding your request here is my question: "There were 880 occupations and 72 deaths, according to official numbers from your own government and that covers only up to March. How do you explain having missed the target so badly?"

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Brazil to Decriminalize and Distribute Drugs

    Brazil’s federal government is discussing a decree to regulate the policy of reducing the ...

    Losing Patience with Lula

    Lula and his advisers have resurrected the old “supply-side” and “trickle-down” arguments pioneered by ...

    Best-seller Books, Plays and Movies

    (*Before Cardoso) The public sector has played a crucial role in Brazil’s economic development. ...

    LETTERS

    The partnership between Caetano and Gil is one of the most fertile and lasting ...

    Brazil Gets Ready to Cash Its Carbon Credits

    Alongside India, Brazil holds a leadership position in the Clean Development Mechanism (CDL) market, ...

    Brazil Searching Candidates for This Year’s Teacher Prize

    Inscriptions for this year’s Teacher Prize for Brazilian public school teachers will close on ...

    Brazilian Shoe Exports Are Down 20 Million Pairs. Thousands Protest in Brasí­lia

    Three thousand representatives of the Brazilian leather and footwear sector were in BrasÀ­lia to ...

    Brazilians Save One Quarter of GDP

    Between July and September, Brazilians saved the equivalent of nearly a quarter of all ...

    Ready for Lula

    With 95 percent of next year’s budget already allotted, which is binding for the ...