Brazilian Congress Ethics Council Votes to Expel Deputy Involved in Vote Buying Scandal

    The decision by members of Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies’ Ethics Council to approve a report recommending that deputy Romeu Queiroz (from the PTB party, Minas Gerais state) be deprived of his parliamentary mandate is seen as a "trend" that is expected to be repeated in the analysis of other cases.

    This opinion was voiced by the president of the Council, Ricardo Izar (PTB, São Paulo). "Beginning with this vote, a trend has been established. In the eyes of the Council, having received money, regardless of where it came from and what it was for, will be enough for us to recommend punishment."

    The Council is considering 11 expulsion motions related to lawmakers’ involvement in the purported monthly allowance ("mensalão") scheme.

    Queiroz is charged with brokering the collection of US$ 207.2 thousand (R$ 450 thousand) for the PTB in 2003-2004. He claims that he was unaware of the illegal origin of the money, most of which was transferred by the advertising executive, Marcos Valério, at the request of the PT. He also contends that it was up to the party to report the funds.

    In Queiroz’s view, by adopting a judgment "criterion," the Ethics Council runs the risk of committing errors. "The Council wants to use the existence of unreported campaign funds (‘caixa 2’) as a criterion for other cases.

    I did not use ‘caixa 2’ funds," he argues. "Even so, every case is different. I don’t believe that everybody should be punished in the same way. Society is demanding punishment of those who were guilty, not the innocent," he adds.

    Deputy Carlos Sampaio (PSDB, São Paulo), who is a member of the Council, disagrees with the conclusion that, beginning with Queiroz’s case, the Ethics Council will treat the other cases in an identical manner.

    "We are mindful that each case is different – and that they should be analyzed individually," he states.

    He acknowledges, however, that the unlawful activity practiced by Queiroz could be characterized as the creation of a "caixa 2" for electoral campaigns.

    "The classic instance of a ‘caixa 2’ is when the funds are for the campaign of the deputy who raises them. But deputy Romeu Queiroz’s case is also one of ‘caixa 2,’ only, in this case, for the party. Both activities are blameworthy and reproachable, but they are distinct," he affirmed.

    Agência Brasil

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (2)

    • Guest

      Need help with a college question
      In Brzil if you see a brazilian in a restaturant reach behind his head and grab the opposite earlobe …what is he indicating.???

    • Guest

      (UN)Ethics firing (UN)Ethics?
      What you guys are thinking?

      Firing 1 corrupt politician?
      How about the rest?

      They ALL in the same boat.

      I hope the boat goes down fast, but they are the lice, the country just can’t get rid of them.

      There you go, (UN)Ethics firing (UN)Ethics. ….

      Why? I tell you why. The guy didn’t split the $$$ among their partners in crime.

      HE HE HE HE HE HE

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    David and Sean Goldman

    Musings on an Interview with Sean, the American Boy Abducted to Brazil

    Everyone knows that "Sean" doesn't want to leave Brazil and we also know that ...

    Biofach Latin America in Brazil

    Organic Global Community Gathers in Brazil for BioFach Latin America

    Organic products from 12 countries will be presented by 300 exhibitors during the BioFach ...

    Brazil: Waiting for Lula… to Get Out

    Lula’s administration is still mired in inefficiency and inability to deliver any programs to ...

    Brazil Sends Books to East Timor to Promote Portuguese

    The rural libraries program Arca das Letras (Chest of Letters) developed by the Brazilian ...

    President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva

    Lula Moved to Tears on TV While Talking About Own Accomplishments

    Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva broke down to tears in front of ...

    Presidential hopeful Dilma Rousseff

    Why Brazilians Should Elect Dilma Rousseff the Next President of Brazil

    A little over four years ago, in September 2006 “Brazzil” published one of my ...

    Brazil Convention: Countries Far from Consensus on Traditional Knowledge

    The protection of traditional knowledge is one of the main themes that have been ...

    Brazil’s Domestic Debt Is Out of Control, Says Expert

    In recent years Brazil’s foreign debt has been falling, while domestic debt has been ...

    It’s Carnaval in Brazil. All Trouble Is Gone.

    Brazilians love to party. Carnaval may have officially ended at dawn on Ash Wednesday ...

    Brazilian Elections Theme of Business Breakfast in New York

    Weil, Gotshal & Manges, the international law firm headquartered in New York, will serve ...