Brazil Urges Creation of Mercosur Parliament But Overlooks FTAA

    Uruguay and Brazil have urged Mercosur partners Argentina and Paraguay to speed up an institutional reform of Mercosur in order to bring greater transparency and continuity to its policies, and put free trade talks with the European Union back on track.

    The call was made by the two nations’ newly-created Consultation and Political Accord Mechanism (MCCP). Uruguay’s Deputy Foreign Minister Belela Herrera and her Brazilian counterpart Samuel Pinheiro Guimarães launched the call at the inaugural meeting of the mechanism earlier this month in Montevideo.

    The officials said that stronger institutions would bring about transparency, stability and predictability to the trading bloc’s policies and help consolidate macroeconomic coordination, improve competitiveness, and integrate Mercosur’s chains of production.

    They also renewed their nations’ support to the proposed South American “energy ring” and called on Mercosur governments to redouble efforts in order to re-launch the stalled free trade talks with the EU.

    In an ambitious 32-point act, they also called for further trade liberalization amongst member states and for the elimination of the double clamping of duties on non-Mercosur goods.

    But despite their sanguine approach, the truth is that none of these issues will come about easily. For starters, the top item on the “institutional reform” agenda is the creation of a Mercosur parliament.

    This is a highly contentious subject, mainly because governments in the area are reluctant to hand over decision-making to a supranational authority.

    “There is fear in these (Mercosur) governments to delegate part of our national sovereignties in order to build a regional sovereignty” Argentine Economic Integration Undersecretary Eduardo Sigal told a recent seminar. “This is a quantum leap that requires great political determination”.

    But there’s more – both Uruguay and Paraguay have made clear that they would be ill at ease with a system of proportional representation such as the one prevailing in the European Parliament, since their delegates would be badly outnumbered by Brazilian and Argentine legislators who could easily impose their decisions.

    At a special session held May 30, Paraguay’s Senate expressed full support for the Mercosur parliament but under the condition that all four members get the same number of seats in it. The 1991 Treaty of Asuncion that laid the foundations for Mercosur upholds the principle of equality among member states, they argued.

    The MCCP expressed optimism that the Mercosur-EU meeting to be held September 2 in Brussels will produce “substantial progress” and that “negotiations will result in an effective growth in trade between the two blocs”. Talks have stalled over market access, with Mercosur decrying EU’s farm support policies.

    However Argentine government officials see three possible scenarios for that meeting:

    1- Negotiations are indeed revived and they move full steam ahead;

    2- Negotiations are revived, but a less ambitious, “light” agenda is adopted in order to salvage the deal;

    3- A wait-and-see attitude is espoused to give governments time to see what comes out of the upcoming round of global talks to be held by the World Trade Organization next December in Hong Kong.

    “Why quarrel now about (EU) agricultural support policies when the issue will likely be tackled in Hong Kong?” one Argentine official said, suggesting that any substantial move would probably have to wait at least until next year.

    Significantly, no mention of the now dormant Free Trade Area of the Americas – Washington’s proposal to set up a free-trade zone from Alaska to Tierra del Fuego – was made in the MCCP document.

    This article appeared originally in Mercopress –


    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


    You May Also Like

    Brazil Uses Sports to Promote Changes in the Country

    Brazil’s Minister of Sports, Agnelo Queiroz, declared that "The government is using public policy ...

    São Paulo aircraft carrier

    Brazil Is Too Good of a Target to Be Without the A-Bomb

    Brazil should develop the technological capacity to manufacture nuclear weapons, one of the country’s ...

    An offshore oilfield in Brazil

    Brazil’s Challenge: Avoiding Oil Curse, Says Minister

    According to a close aide to Brazilian president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, Brazil ...

    Brazil Rewards Its Best Writers

    Mongólia, a novel by Bernardo Carvalho, was one of the big winners of the ...

    Antônia Joyce Venâncio and her dolls

    All But White: Brazil’s Treasure-Trove of Black, Oriental, Handicapped Dolls

    Businesswoman Antônia Joyce Venâncio has been having success since she bet on a market ...

    Brazil Makes Biofuel a National Priority

    Brazil’s President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva said today that few countries are as ...

    Brazil to Stop Requiring Visa from Americans

    The President of Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies, Severino Cavalcanti (from the Progressive Party of ...

    Brazilian ex-Finance Minister Mailson Nóbrega

    Mercosur Is Not Viable as Economic Bloc, Says Brazil’s Former Minister

    "Mercosur has become irrelevant and too complicated, and even more when Venezuela is finally ...

    Cargo trucks in Brazil

    Transportation Costs Are Stunting Exports in Brazil and LatAm

    Latin American exports' growth depends more on lower transport costs than on reduction of ...

    Brazilian Army hands out food in Haiti

    Haiti Is Giving Brazil a Chance to Prove Its Mettle Beyond Cheap Talk

    After a promising beginning that included, among other accomplishments, being the second country in ...