As Walking Metamorphosis Brazil’s Lula Has Become Target for Left and Right

    Brazilian president Lula

    Brazilian president Lula The long interview given by Brazilian President Lula to O Estado de S. Paulo newspaper on August 26th shows the enigma, the contradiction he and his government represent, in all its dimensions. Whether they agree with the government, or radically criticize it, from the right, or from the left, anyone can pick out some or other reply to confirm their own view.

    Taking into account the interview’s complete five pages, no one can fail to see that it seeks to square the circle for a government that attracts, at one and the same time, the most relentless opposition from the mainstream Brazilian press, the support of the great majority of the impoverished classes, criticism from an important part of the left and support from big business.


    Lula likes to use the expression of the Brazilian singer Raul Seixas “walking metamorphosis” to try and define himself, to suggest that in this way he has managed to reject the temptations of what he calls “principle-ism”, referring to what in his judgment would be dogmatic opinions.


    This manages to capture his political and ideological transformation since he erupted into Brazil’s political life as a labor leader in opposition to the military dictatorship, 30 years ago now. However, it does make very clear that while Lula adapted to material conditions so as to exercise power for all Brazilians, that same move may be interpreted as being an authentic ideological conversion to the operative conditions for the reproduction of capitalism in Brazil.


    The first thing to note in relation to that is the consolidation of the monopolistic, anti-democratic nature of the Brazilian press. This, even though he won majority support from the people, according to the electoral results nine months ago that led to his re-election, and even though the opinion polls confirm – despite new crises thoroughly exploited by the press – the huge support he enjoys especially among the impoverished, who are the great majority of the population.


    Despite this, the government’s point of view is not presented on a daily basis in the mainstream press, which is monolithic in its fierce opposition, totally excluding a plurality of views.


    Lula does not conceal that what he considers his government’s greatest success is exactly the thing for which he has taken most criticism from the left: economic policy. But immediately he adds on his foreign policy priorities : alliances in Latin America and with the world’s South.


    When he is asked to what extent these policies are his own rather than ones inherited from his predecessor (Fernando Henrique Cardoso), he questions that, saying that to have sustained the policies he inherited would have bankrupted the country.


    In his vision, that economic leadership has been the precondition for the great success of his social policies. An indispensable part of his program of government stems from the Letter to Brazilians, in which he undertook to maintain inherited commitments – above all with financial capital, which had mounted a strong speculative attack in 2002 when faced then with Lula’s electoral win. This allowed him to do better than the 35% support obtained in his previous presidential candidacies to reach, in the end, 61%.


    With this he tries to justify the sacrifices he imposed in his first year of government, when he increased the primary surplus above that demanded by the IMF. Lula tries to play down recent conflicts in Brazil’s foreign policy by confirming Brazil’s interest in building the South American gas pipeline.


    The president also argues that the nature of the Bank of the South is still under discussion. He repeats Brazil’s willingness to be more generous towards the region’s less developed countries (Bolivia, Paraguay and Uruguay)


    He concedes that concerns over the argument about ethanol and food production are not without foundation. He says, “In a country like Mexico, for example, the high price of corn, causes a serious problem because its people eat so much tortilla”, concluding “fuel policy cannot conflict with food policy”.


    Discounting disputes with Hugo Chavez suggested in the press, he points out that Venezuela is buying three tanker loads of ethanol from Brazil.


    Still, Lula does not mention the nature of new relations with the United States based on mutual visits with Bush, nor does he touch on other issues for which he has been criticized from more left wing sectors in Brazil.


    He avoids themes like genetically manipulated crops, the closed classification of files from the dictatorship, repression of community radios, slow progress on land reform and, likewise, the de facto independence of the Central Bank and unrestricted capital flows in financial sphere.


    Emir Sader, 64, is a Brazilian Marxist sociologist. He has taught philosophy and political science at USP (Universidade de São Paulo), Brazil’s most renowned university and now teaches sociology at Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro (UERJ).


    Translated by Tortilla con Sal.

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Brazil’s CVRD Sells Firm, But Keeps It

    Brazil’s Companhia Vale do Rio Doce (CVRD) announced that it has sold its stake ...

    Brazil’s Industrial Capacity Nearing Its Limit

    Brazilian market analysts and financial consultants interviewed last week by Brazil’s Central Bank expressed ...

    Brazil Has Reason to Smile, Says Lula

    Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva devoted today’s edition of his biweekly radio ...

    Brazil's Capezio

    Brazilian Ballet Shoe Maker Dancing on Foreign Floors

    Capezio, a traditional Brazilian maker of ballet shoes, shoes, gym and dance clothes and ...

    Brazilian economy shrinks

    IMF Sees Brazil’s GDP Shrinking 1.3% This Year and Growing 2.5% in 2010

    According to the latest estimates from the International Monetary Fund, the Latin American economy ...

    A jacket made by Brazil's Recicla Jeans program

    Favela Fashion Brings Pride and Jobs to Brazilian Slum

    Residents of Paraisópolis (Paradise City), the second largest favela (shantytown) in the city of ...

    Brazil's frontpage paper shows violent protests against Bush

    Clashes with Police and 22 Injured in Anti-Bush Protests in Brazil

    United States president George Bush arrived late Thursday to São Paulo for a 24-hour ...

    Without Brazil, Indy Is Not the Same

    Brazilian drivers Kanaan and Junqueira ended 2nd and 5th at Indy. Still this was ...

    US Senator Richard Lugar

    Helping Uruguay American Senator Hopes to Force Brazil to Do More Business with US

    Richard Lugar, the ranking Republican on the Foreign Relations Committee in the US senate, ...