Opening the Gates

Opening the Gates

    Many journalists and media executives tend to believe
    that opening the media to foreign capital
    their final hope for survival.

    Paulo Rebêlo

    As expected, on April 4th, the Senate’s Constitution and Justice Committee has approved a bill opening up Brazilian
    media companies to foreign capital. Until now, a 60-year old law banned foreign ownership of the country’s media. The
    foreign participation cannot exceed 30 percent of the voting stockholders. Officially.

    This means that from now on any company in Brazil may be a major shareholder or own a media vehicle, such as
    radio and TV stations, newspapers, magazines, etc and have access to the stock market. Before the approval of the new law,
    media companies in Brazil had to be owned (officially) by a Brazilian citizen or someone naturalized Brazilian for at least ten
    years. That explains why the media in Brazil is commonly called a big family business, in which media companies are passed
    from father to son for generations.

    The new foreign investment law intends to help the organization and, especially, assist in getting fresh loans. The
    editorial policies from broadcast and newspaper companies should remain as defined in the Brazilian Constitution:
    exclusive responsibility of native or naturalized Brazilians.

    According to São Paulo Senator Romeu Tuma, from the rightwing PFL (Partido da Frente Liberal—Liberal Front
    Party), the project has already been classified as "urgent" by the Senate. It still has to be approved by the full Senate, but no
    one is expecting any surprise there. Professionals from the media believe that major companies will start getting foreign
    investments for floating capital right away.


    Qualified professionals being fired, magazines being closed, and lack of high-quality content
    in newspapers are just some of the plagues affecting the Brazilian media industry these days. There is also the pressure of
    the so-called risk Brazil, that is, the currency devaluation and the economic retraction together with the decline in
    consumption, which in plain economese characterizes a full-grown recession.

    The risk Brazil has direct influence upon newspapers, magazines and radio and TV stations, all on their knees due to
    products and services they have imported in the last few years. Those who work in the media are feeling deeply the pain. Those
    who don’t, may follow what is happening through the news. Companies have accumulated huge debts in U.S. dollar a few
    years ago, when one dollar bought one "real" (the Brazilian currency). But thanks to the currency devaluation, now one dollar
    is worth about 2.6 reais—a 260 percent increase.

    Many journalists and media executives tend to believe that opening the media to foreign capital is their final hope for
    survival. Is that so? Foreign companies are not willing to participate in bankrupt businesses neither are they interested in buying
    stocks from archaic family companies before these companies clean the house themselves.

    In South America, Brazil is the leading country, occupying almost 50 percent of the continent’s territory. It has close
    to 8 million people connected to the Internet, an avid population for goods and services. The foreign capital will indeed
    arrive, but no one knows at what price. For sure, it won’t come for free, it never does.

    It’s not hard to find journalists, sometimes in a bar, saying that Brazil will see a new hiring frenzy when the money
    arrives. It’s a sweet illusion, made better by a few beers, when basic concepts of economy are usually forgotten.


     It’s well known that there’s nothing in the books that can prevent, in the near future, the
    insertion of a new paragraph in the law allowing foreign participation to exceed 30 percent. For those who don’t remember or
    aren’t very familiar with the matter, the original bill didn’t include any restriction against foreigners managing TV stations. The
    Senate introduced such restrictions only after being challenged by protests.

    Few people believe that the Brazilian government has enough resources (and will) to insure that the 30 percent limit
    of participation in the media companies will be observed. Theory and practice may be worlds apart, and often they are.
    With or without foreign money there is a deepening crisis in the Brazilian media.

    It’s quite hilarious to imagine the presumption of smaller companies thinking that they will be able to get easy loans
    or to put their little hands on foreign funds, after the project gets definitely approved. Many seem to forget the economic
    rule of thumb: there’s no free meal.


    Right now, Brazil’s government is putting together the Social Communication Council,
    with primary goals yet to be defined. It will be comprised by politicians, artists and employers’ representatives, which will
    represent the Congress in order to deal with media companies and discuss programming on Brazilian TVs. Many believe the
    Council might lead to a new, legalized, kind of censorship. Others suggest that such an invention won’t solve anything and that
    the market itself will create its own rules.

    Nowadays, about 70 percent of radio stations and 25 percent of TV stations in Brazil are controlled by politicians.
    These stations are not big companies—don’t have the same credibility as the major outlets—and probably aren’t attractive
    enough to foreign investors. Which makes even more important a debate about the Council’s role, since there will be politicians
    in it. Until now, no one knows who will they be. Will they be exempt people? Of course no one is thinking the Council as
    being an action between friends. Or is it?

    Paulo Rebêlo ( is an assistant-editor at and the correspondent in Brazil for
    Wired News.

    comments to

    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


    You May Also Like

    Of Faith, Poverty and Beauty

    The idea of staying indoors copying other people’s ideas just didn’t go over with ...

    No Good Intentions

    It’s a good bet that President Fernando Henrique Cardoso will close out his second ...

    Teuto Laboratory

    Brazilian Lab Expands Exports of Generic Drugs to Libya

    A Brazilian lab, Teuto laboratory, from Goiânia, capital of the state of Goiás, in ...

    The Lula-cheering crowd has disappeared from the Brazilian streets

    An Autopsy of the Corruption That Sapped Brazil’s Ruling Party

    "Hear me, citizens of Brazil, senators, and deputies…"Thus commenced the televised coverage of the ...

    Worker cuts sugar cane in Brazil

    Brazil’s Ethanol Producers Call the US’s Free-Trade Bluff

    Contrary to the usual outcome of Washington’s subsidies to U.S. farmers, recent grants for ...


    A Soul Portrait Once a central port in the Portuguese colonial network of commerce ...

    Dreams to Share River Waters Closer to Reality in Brazil

    With 36 votes in favor, Brazil’s National Council of Water Resources approved the opinion ...

    Nélida Piñon

    Reading Brazilian Piñon, I Was Glad I Wasn’t the Caliph

    Nélida Piñon is among Brazil’s best known writers, and Voices of the Desert is ...

    Chinese yuan

    Lula Wants Brazilians and Chinese to Eliminate Dollar for Trade Between Them

    Brazil and China will start conducting business with each other in their own currencies ...