Brazil: Lula’s Words Alone Won’t Do

Brazil: Lula's Words Alone Won't Do

    Brazil’s pension reform seems in jeopardy. By showing weakness
    against the judiciary, the
    Lula administration has put its credibility
    at stake. Voters are starting to wonder whether Lula is a
    tiger and foreign investors are selling off Brazilian securities.
    The Brazil risk is rising once again,
    as is the dollar.


    John Fitzpatrick


    At the time of this writing, President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva should have been packing his bags. He was due to visit
    South Africa and Namibia as well as three Portuguese-speaking countries—Angola, Mozambique and São Tomé and
    Príncipe. However, domestic problems arising from the government’s pension reform proposals have led to the trip being
    postponed. Lula’s top advisers want him around to have the final word on last-minute alterations if the government is to win the
    first vote on the issue, which is set to take place in the Lower House on August 6.

    While one can see that this might not be the best moment for the President to spend 10 days in Africa, one cannot
    help but ask whether postponing the trip was really necessary. After all, the government has had the whole of July, when a
    special session of Congress was held at great public expense, to resolve points of contention. Modern technology means that
    Lula could be in virtual contact throughout the trip, and still make key decisions. 

    However, this is a pointless criticism made by a foreign observer who should know better by now. The Brazilian
    way of facing a crisis is simply to ditch everything at a moment’s notice, even though this may cause offense to others, and
    tackle something which, with a bit of organization and preparation, should have been settled before it flared up into a crisis.

    The fact that Lula is staying at home shows that either he cannot trust his ministers and advisers to deal with the
    issue, or that he is a hands-on person who wants to be involved personally. The former is the more likely reason. Having made
    this decision, let us hope that Lula also does his homework, and understands what is involved before making any more

    His presence will not ensure that the original proposals will be passed. Not only does his own PT party have a
    significant number of people who disagree with key aspects of the proposals, but support among the other seven parties in the
    mosaic which forms Lula’s alliance is shaky. The fear is that the proposals will be watered down so much that, in the end, they
    will not be enough to lift the crushing financial burden currently imposed by the pension system on public finances.

    Government Gives Ground to Threats

    A small but tenacious group of civil servants who went on strike, and members of the judiciary who threatened to go
    on strike, have shaken the government. Instead of taking on these groups, the administration has given ground. Although
    Lula lashed out at judges and prosecutors last week, and accused them of wanting privileged treatment, it looks as though this
    was just rhetoric and his words will not be backed by action. We will have to wait and see what happens in the coming week,
    but if Lula has postponed his African trip just to stay home and oversee further concessions, then he will be doing the
    country an injustice.

    By showing weakness against the judiciary, the government has put its credibility at stake. Domestically, voters are
    starting to wonder whether Lula is a paper tiger and, externally, foreign investors are selling off Brazilian securities; the Brazil
    risk is rising once again, as is the dollar. On Friday, August 1, the U.S. dollar rose by 2 percent against the real, and crept
    over the R$3 level to end the day at R$3.03. The Brazil risk jumped by 8 percent and here, at home, the São Paulo stock
    market, the BOVESPA, fell by just over 3 percent.

    MST Gets the Blame As Usual 

    It was interesting to see in some reports that the latest activities by the landless peasant movement, the MST, and
    urban homeless people’s groups, have also been held responsible for this loss of confidence in Brazil. Since the media is
    overwhelmingly hostile to the MST, it is difficult to accept much of its coverage of the MST’s activities. The MST has been around
    for a long time, and the idea that foreign investors are suddenly becoming jittery because of it is hard to believe.

    This increased tension over the MST’s activities led to a small demonstration in São Paulo this week by a
    shadowy, reactionary organization called the TFP—the initials stand for Tradition, Family and Property. This is part of an
    international anti-Communist grouping, which also claims to be Catholic. Its members are generally creepy-looking, middle-aged
    older men who wear medieval cloaks, and are the kind of people who supported military rule.

    Although they claim that the family is one of their sacred causes, it is noticeable how often they are accompanied by
    younger, rather simple-looking men, and teenagers as they walk about the upscale Higienópolis district where they have their
    headquarters. In nearby Santa Cecilia they have set up a "shrine" consisting of a small statue of the Virgin Mary, which they
    say was bombed by Communist terrorists in the 1960s. Having people like this on the streets is a much more serious threat
    to Brazilian democracy than peasant squatters.


    John Fitzpatrick is a Scottish journalist who first visited Brazil in 1987 and has lived in São Paulo since 1995.
    He writes on politics and finance and runs his own company, Celtic Comunicações—, which specializes in editorial and translation services for Brazilian and foreign clients. You can reach him at

    © John Fitzpatrick 2003

    This article appeared originally in
    Infobrazil, at

    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


    You May Also Like

    Time to Share the Wealth in Brazil

    José Dirceu, Chief of Staff of the Lula administration, says that everybody in Brazil ...

    Brazil Recognizes There’s Still a Long Way to Include Indians in Society

    The executive secretary of Brazil’s Ministry of Justice, Luiz Paulo Barreto, participated, Tuesday, March ...

    Brazilian cargo ship

    Brazil and Neighbors Are the Ones Shaping Up Any New US-Latin America Relations

    Global economic disruption makes it seem events are overtaking analysis faster than people can ...

    Brazilian industry

    Blaming World for “Hidden Protectionism” Brazil Spends US$ 35 Bi to Protect Its Industry

    The Brazilian government announced on Tuesday tax cuts and other stimulus measures worth about ...

    Venezuela Not Ready for Prime Time in a Mercosur Dominated by Brazil

    Venezuela’s July 4 official accession to the Mercado Común del Sur (Mercosur), of which ...

    Brazil’s Agro Exports to Middle East Grow 55%

    Brazilian agribusiness exports to the Middle East have risen 55% from January to September ...

    Chief of BNDES Bank Guarantees Hot Economy for Brazil in Coming Months

    The president of Brazil’s National Economic and Social Development Bank (BNDES), Guido Mantega, said ...

    Keeping the Flame

    Who are these men and women dressed in colorful and festive garb? They are ...

    Brazilians Rescued from Airports’ Long Lines and Delays by Air Force

    TAM, Brazil’s largest airline, announced Friday night, December 22, that it had leased seven planes ...