Accused of Bandits Brazilian Judges Refuse to Be Judged by Other than Their Own Peers

    Eliana Calmon

    Eliana Calmon A majority of the members of Brazil’s National Judiciary Council (CNJ) signed a document refuting declarations by the CNJ Inspector General, Eliana Calmon, after she said that there were bandits in togas in the Brazilian justice system.

    In a note read at a CNJ session yesterday, Tuesday, September 27, the president of the CNJ, and Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Cezar Peluso, called the accusations baseless.

    Peluso’s note was signed by 12 of the 15 members of the CNJ. Eliana Calmon, a representative of the Bar Association (OAB) and another judge did not vote at the session yesterday.

    Without directly citing Calmon, the note said in part: “Without identifying persons, without due process, accusations are made without proof and doubt cast on the honor of thousands of judges who daily toil away at their work of impartial and honest judgment ensuring the safety of society and the stability of a democratic state under the rule of law.”

    In an interview to the São Paulo Newspaper Association, Eliana Calmon declared that in the Brazilian judiciary “… there is a grave problem with the infiltration of bandits who hide behind togas.”

    The Supreme Court is scheduled to judge a suit brought by an association of judges, the Brazilian Association of Magistrates (AMB), which is attempting to restrict CNJ powers to investigate and punish judges for corruption and misdeeds.

    According to Eliana Calmon, any restrictions on the powers of CNJ oversight and investigation is the first step to impunity for bad judges

    However, the president of the judge’s association (AMB), Nelson Calandra, disagrees. He called the remarks by Eliana Calmon erroneous because they were generalizations and said it was important to put restrictions on the ability of the CNJ to judge and punish judges as that is an attribution of local courts. In other words: judges should be judged by other judges on the same court.

    The attempt by the AMB to restrict CNJ activities has resulted in a tug of war that could redefine the role of the council that was established in response to decades of complaints of nepotism, inefficiency, corruption and the law’s delay in the judicial system.

    The AMB seeks to have CNJ decisions on disciplinary and administrative activities of judges ruled unconstitutional. With CNJ corrective powers severely reduced, the council will be mainly restricted to its less controversial duties: to plan, manage and modernize the judicial system.

    If the AMB suit wins out and limits are set on the CNJ, it will be able to take disciplinary action only after local judicial oversight agencies have completely exhausted due process.

    That is, after the local judges have judged the local judges. This would be a return to the way things worked before 2005 when the CNJ was created (by constitutional amendment #45) as part of a Judiciary reform by the Congress in response to popular demands for closer oversight of what courts and judges were doing or not doing.

    Gasoline Tax

    In the economic front, the Brazilian government has taken steps in a juggling act involving gasoline content and prices to avoid an increase in final prices for the consumer. The amount of ethanol that is added to gasoline will be reduced from 25% to 20% on October 1 (the sugarcane harvest will be less than expected).

    Normally that would increase the price of gasoline (which is more expensive than ethanol), but the government will reduce one of its fuel taxes, the “Cide,” from R$230 to R$192.60 per cubic meter of fuel.

    The secretary of Economic Oversight at the Ministry of Finance, Antônio Henrique Silveira, says the measure is exclusively due to a small increase in price that could occur with the change in the mixture of gasoline and sugarcane-based ethanol. He adds that the measure is no guarantee that prices will remain stable. “Prices are free,” he declared.

    In practical terms, the government has reduced the Cide from R$0.23 to R$0.19 per liter. That will translate into a loss of some R$50 million in tax revenue for the government.

    ABr

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (1)

    • J. Corleone

      Huuum, it sure smells bad, but it does not surprise me, since….better keep my mouth shut, so the bugs won´t enter!
      In Sicily is the same!

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Dreaming of Rio, in Tripoli

    We have warmed to one another. I now feel it is the moment to ...

    Just a driving dog

    Driving in Brazil Taught Me That’s Wrong Respecting Others Too Much

    I’ve never driven in Rome, New Delhi, or Lagos. So, I can’t honestly say ...

    Brazil, Very Unfriendly to Labor and Children, Says ICFTU

    A new report by the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU) on core ...

    The National newspaper

    Emirates’s Al Jazira Buys Brazil Soccer Player for Record US$ 20 Million

    Brazilian football striker Ricardo Oliveira's hiring by the Al Jazira team, based in Abu ...

    Brazil Celebrates UN’s Role as the Planet’s Peace Keeper

    The United Nations is indispensable to world peace, remarked the Brazilian Minister of Foreign ...

    Obama in Rio with family

    Brazil Is Example of Democracy for Arab World, Says Obama in Rio

    US President Barack Obama, in a show of support for Brazil’s rising global economic ...

    A Brazilian School Where the US and the World Can Learn the Beautiful Game

    The Brazilian Football School (EBF), center for physical education of the state of Rio ...

    Brazil: The Tupinikim Indians Vs. Aracruz Celulose War Gets Ugly

    On September 12, 22 days late, Brazil’s National Foundation for Indigenous People (Funai) sent ...

    LETTERS

    Organized over the Internet, gringo sambistas from 19 countries invaded the Sambadrome in Rio ...

    Presidential candidate Dilma Rousseff

    Doctors Declare Presidential Candidate Dilma Rousseff Cured of Lymphoma

    Dilma Rousseff, the Brazilian presidential candidate for the Workers Party ruling coalition underwent a ...