Gay coupleA spokesperson for an umbrella group of gays, lesbians, bisexuals and transsexuals (GLBT), the Rainbow Group of Rio de Janeiro (Grupo Arco-Íris), called the Supreme Court decision to recognize stable homosexual unions as legal, “A historical conquest. This is really a date to commemorate. It is something we have been fighting for for over 15 years,” declared Cléber Vicente of the Grupo Arco-Íris.

    However, although the decision does create a legal basis for a stable homosexual union, it does not make same-sex marriage legal and does not quite recognize a civil union although the path to civil unions for homosexuals is now open.

    Vicente went on to say that the ruling leaves various issues unresolved that will need congressional action, such as what he called “complete citizenship for the Brazilian homosexual movement that includes the right to a civil union.”

    According to Vicente, the Rainbow Group wants equal rights, not privileges.

    Brazil’s Federal Bar Association (Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil – OAB) commemorated last week’s decision by the Supreme Court recognizing that  homosexuals can have a stable union. The OAB said the ruling was in accordance with the principles of human equality and dignity described in the Brazilian constitution.

    “This is something that is part of Brazilian life and society. It is something that needed to be recognized by the courts so as to protect the rights of those who live in a situation similar to a stable union,” declared Ophir Cavalcante, the OAB president.

    The Ruling

    ‘The Supreme Court of Brazil has given legal recognition to stable homosexual unions. That means a gay couple will now have the same rights (and obligations) as a family entity (entidade familiar).

    In practical terms, a gay couple will be considered a family and the partners will be able to give one another an inheritance or a pension, share social security benefits and health plans, include the companion on an income tax return, as well as, in the case of separation, receive alimony and property. And as of now, a gay couple can adopt children and register them in their names.

    That is just a small list because, according to Maria Berenice Dias, of the Brazilian Institute of the Family Rights (Instituto Brasileiro de Direito da Família – Ibdfam), heterosexual couples had no less than 112 restricted rights that a gay couple did not have.

    The vote at the Supreme Court was unanimous (10-0), with one justice not participating. Justice Antonio Dias Toffoli recused himself because of work he did when he was the head of the Government Attorney Office (Advocacia Geral da União – AGU).

    In spite of the unanimous vote, three justices, Lewandowski, Mendes and Peluso, pointed out that the decision was limited and did not resolve all the issues in the question of homosexual unions.

    The judges insisted that what was needed was specific legislation on rights, legislation that only the Congress could take care of.

    The Chief Justice (presidente) of the Supreme Court, Cezar Peluso, made it clear that there should be a specific law by the Congress, saying Congress was responsible for more specific legislation on the rights of homosexuals.

    “We convoke the Legislative branch to take on this task – something they have not been eager to do in the past: implement appropriate legislation,” declared the Chief Justice.

    According to Peluso, the Supreme Court decision was a kind of stopgap measure due to a legal lacuna that should be filled by a law. The Chief Justice said the court had ruled that hetero- and homosexual relations were similar, but that did not mean that in legal terms they were automatically equal.

    “Today’s important decision opens the door for action by the legislature. Members of Congress must step up and do their part by creating the appropriate legislation that will ensure that the Court’s ruling will be effective,” declared Peluso.

    Lewandowski added that the decision “…was an opening of the doors for homosexual unions, but not a closing of the doors in the Legislature.”

    A number of bills on homosexual rights are bogged down in the Brazilian Congress and have been bogged down for a long time with little possibility of quick approval due to strong opposition by the Catholic church and many members of both Houses of Congress.

    ABr

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (1)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Jeitinho Land

    In cases where regulations have to be confronted, Brazilians pride themselves on being especially ...

    Presidents Hugo Chavez and Lula

    Staying Out of US-Inspired FTAA Is a Good Thing, Says Brazil

    With Venezuela included Mercosur has "the potential of becoming a trade block of the ...

    Brazil and Argentina Join Forces in Cyberwar Against the US

    Brazilian Defense minister Celso Amorim met his Argentine counterpart Agustín Rossi and offered to ...

    Brazil Goes High Tech to Fight Fruit Fly

    Brazil’s Ministry of Science and Technology will invest US$ 1.34 million in a project ...

    WWF's headquarters in Corumbá, Brazil

    US College Students Get Chance to Meet Brazilian Amazon Up Close

    American students from several US states have been selected to study conservation in the ...

    Worst in 6 years: 27% of Brazil’s Companies Plan to Cut Jobs

    The projections made by the Brazilian industry for new job offerings in Brazil, in ...

    Presidents Lugo and Lula

    In Paraguay Brasiguayos Are Known for Being Hard Workers and Trigger Happy

    Paraguay is legalizing the situation of Brazilians who live and work around the city ...

    Brazilian farm

    Brazil to Finance Agriculture at a Clip of US$ 46 Billion this Year

    Brazil's 2009-2010 crop will count on 93 billion reais (US$ 45.9 billion) in financing, ...

    Folha de S. Paulo newspaper

    In Brazil, Media Still Lives as when the Generals Ruled the Country

    Reporters Without Borders has recently released a report entitled “Brazil, the country of 30 ...

    José Serra and Dilma Rousseff

    New Poll Shows Dilma 12 Points Ahead of Serra in Brazil’s Presidential Runoff

    Dilma Rousseff, Brazil’s presidential candidate handpicked by Lula to succeed him, has widened her ...