• Categories
  • Archives

Brazil’s Justice Minister Resigns with Italian Guerrilla Case Unsolved

Tarso GenroTarso Genro just resigned as Brazil’s minister of Justice to run for governor of Rio Grande do Sul, the southernmost Brazilian state. Talking to reporters on his last day as minister, Genro denied that he had left president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva a problem called Cesare Battisti.

“I am not leaving president Lula a problem. I have made a report. The president is completely aware of my position. Nobody loses, this is a win-win for all. It strengthens democracy,” said Tarso, explaining that the Battisti case expanded the debate in the country and caused people to discuss the issues involved.

“One result was the return of the presidential prerogative to make the final decision,” he claimed.

Last November the Brazilian Supreme Court decided that the president had the final word on the extradition of Battisti, an Italian guerrilla, to Italy.

However, in one of the opinions on the case justice Eros Grau found a loophole which could make it possible for the case to return to the court if Lula decides to allow Battisti to remain in Brazil. This is because by doing so Brazil would be breaking an extradition treaty with Italy that dates from 1989.

Battisti was tried and sentenced to life in prison for four murders in Italy in the 1970s when he was a member of an extremist left-wing group (two of the people he killed were low-level government employees – a customs official and a policeman).

Battisti escaped from prison in the 1980s and lived in France for many years before going to Brazil in 2004. In 2007 he was arrested in Brazil (for using false documents) and Italy immediately requested his extradition.

In January 2009, the minister of Justice, Tarso Genro, extended Battisti refugee status after the Brazilian Refugee Commission had denied it.

The case reached the Supreme Court in November 2009 where not one, not two, but three decisions were made. All three decisions were by 5 to 4 votes. There are eleven justices on the Brazilian Supreme Court but two of them did not participate.

First, the court ruled that Battisti should not have been given refugee status basically because his crimes were not considered political. Second, the court ruled that he should be extradited to Italy. Third, the court ruled that the final decision was the president’s, basically because international relations are involved.

ABr

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

We are flunking the challenge

The Brazilian education level is so low in Latin America that only Guatemala, the ...

Brazilian Troops March for Independence Day and Guarantee Peaceful Elections

Brazil’s Independence Day, September 7 – Brazil became independent from Portugal in 1822 – ...

After Mexico’s Success Brazil Considers Selling 100-year Bonds

The Brazilian government is thinking about selling 100-year bonds after Mexico succeeded in offering ...

In Latin America U.S. Military Is the Problem Not the Solution

Pax Americana has got problems – not just in the Middle East and East ...

Brazil: Presidential Elections Shaping Up as Referendum on Environment

Brazilian senator Marina Silva, Brazil's former environment minister has left the ruling Workers' Party, ...

Bio Jewel, a Brazilian Product Made for Export

Countries in Europe, like Italy, France, Portugal and Spain are the main buyers of ...

Does Zero Hunger Make Sense? or Cardoso Was Right After All

In Brazil, hunger and malnutrition are part of a syndrome that includes illiteracy, inadequate ...

Irresponsible and Lazy, Brazilians Like to Live Dangerously

One of the most disturbing aspects of the ongoing scandal involving allegations that Brazil’s ...

Brazil, Venezuela and Cuba Greet Obama with Hope and Skepticism

The Brazilian government has made it clear that it hopes that the new American ...

Brazil Afraid Senegalese Immigrants Might Bring Ebola

The state government of Acre in northern Brazil has urged Brazilian federal authorities to ...