Brazil’s Supreme Upholds Censorship of Renowned Daily O Estado

    Front page of O Estado

    Front page of O Estado The Brazilian Federal Supreme Court, the highest ranking court in Brazil, ruled against an appeal filed by O Estado de S. Paulo, among the three most important daily newspapers in the country, requesting the reversal of a lower court decision that prevents it from publishing information relating to a federal police investigation.

    The enquiry in question dealt with the actions of businessman Fernando Sarney, who is the son of Senate President and former president of Brazil José Sarney.

    The lower court decision, which the newspaper regards as an act of censorship, was in response to a request filed by Fernando Sarney and has already been in effect for 130 days.

    O Estado de S. Paulo had published articles revealing the contents of legally authorized telephone recordings obtained during the police investigation, known as Operação Faktor.

    The telephone calls exposed the hiring by the president of the Senate of relatives and political allies, in what would later become a nepotism scandal.

    Fernando Sarney's lawyers accused O Estado of engaging in criminal activity with the publication of the contents of the telephone calls and alleged that the newspaper had harmed the honor of the Sarney family.

    If the newspaper issues any further information about the case it will face a fine of 150,000 Brazilian reais (US$ 86,000) per article published.

    In the appeal presented by O Estado, the newspaper's lawyers argued that the censorship goes against a previous court decision that invalidated the press law (Lei de Imprensa) which was promulgated during the Brazilian military dictatorship (1964-1985).

    The previous ruling, which was issued in April, also conceded full rights to freedom of expression, with explicit references against censorship imposed by the courts.

    The majority of the Supreme Court justices, however, argued that the decision against the newspaper was based on the Constitution and legislation with respect to phone tapping, not the Press Law.

    ABRAJI, the Brazilian Association of Investigative Journalism, condemned the Supreme Court's decision. The organization is concerned over its implications for censorship and press freedom.

    In a statement issued in November, the Inter American Press Association noted its concern about the censorship of O Estado de S. Paulo, stressing that there were already six cases in which judges forbade newspapers from publishing information about specific topics in Brazil.

    The UN rapporteur for the defense of freedom of expression, Frank La Rue, sent a letter to Brazil's Itamaraty, the Foreign Ministry, asking for explanations about the gag rule imposed on the newspaper July 31.

    As usual in cases like that, the letter sent before the decision of the Supreme Court, was not made public. However, since the Brazilian government has ignored the UN document that organization is now preparing a public statement about the matter.

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (0)

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    The Works

    They are into this quality certification process here big-time. Man, it is just sensational. ...

    For Brazil UN Human Rights Council Should Guarantee Life Free from Fear

    The United Nations Human Rights Council is composed of 47 countries, elected among the ...

    EU and Mercosur Betting They Will Soon End Stalemate for Accord

    The European Union seeks to reach an associative agreement with Mercosur in May 2006, ...

    Brazilian real currency

    Brazil Opposition to Appeal to Supreme Against Minimum Wage Law

    In Brazil, no sooner had the country’s Senate passed the new minimum wage law ...

    Morretes in southern Brazil

    In Brazil, Feeling Like a Hero from a Colonial Time Tale

    In the state of Paraná, Brazil, the high coastal range of Serra do Mar ...

    Brothers Jonatas and Davi were homeschooled

    Brazilian Couple Convicted for Homeschooling Their Two Kids

    Cleber and Bernadeth Nunes from Timóteo, a city 196 km (122 miles) from Belo ...

    Brazil Leads Production of Yellow Fever and Rabies Vaccines

    Exports of yellow fever vaccines by Brazil’s Fundação Oswaldo Cruz (Fiocruz) have grown no ...

    Stone Fair Opens in Brazil. Half of Buyers Come from the US

    Brazil is again ready for its annual Vitória Stone Fair, specialized in ornamental stone, ...

    Presidents Kirchner and Lula

    Brazil Calls Protectionism Poison and Not a Cure

    The president of Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, admitted this week that trade ...

    Foot and Mouth Disease Hits Brazil with Close to US$ 2 Billion in Losses

    Foot and mouth export losses are estimated to reach US$ 1.7 billion given the ...