Brazzil

Since 1989 trying to understand Brazil

Search

Custom Search

Cheap Mobile Phones
---------------
Members : 5607
Content : 3496
Content View Hits : 23865401

Who's Online

We have 211 guests online

Login Form



Related Items

Brazzil Magazine
From Brazzil Mag news team
Brazzil Magazine


With Elections and World Cup Brace Yourself for Another Lost Year in Brazil PDF Print E-mail
Written by Richard Hayes   
Sunday, 05 March 2006 13:11

Brazilian players raise World Cup trophyBrazil seems distant from the many prickly issues that are involving the world's powers at the moment. The Hamas' victories in Palestine, the change of ownership of Peninsular and Oriental (P & O), the nuclear ambitions of Iran and India, continuing chaos in Iraq and the spread of avian flue, while they may eventually affect Brazil, are remote.

2006 may turn out to be another lost year for Brazil as far as making progress toward a more just society through economic growth. The 2005 figures show that Gross National Product barely increased enough to compensate for the gain in population.

Congress, for the last eight months involved in parliamentary investigations of many irregularities of sundry nature, have not even looked at any of the much needed reforms of taxation, political parties, labor laws and union activity.

Nor have the investigations resulted in the punishing of those responsible for stealing public funds in the form of kickbacks ranging from the purchase of sneakers for mail carriers to the over invoicing on advertising contracts of federal government entities and the Banco do Brasil. 

Congress, itself discredited for scheduling a special session during vacation months and then seldom showing up for a quorum, will in all probability accomplish little this year because of the elections coming up in October. Providing another distraction will be the World Cup in Germany in June and July. Brazil, a perennial favorite, is seeking its sixth championship in this football (soccer) classic.

Lula, who claims to not have known of the misappropriation of funds going on around him, could wind up being reelected for another four-year term. His approval ratings have improved lately with recent polls showing that he would defeat any of the possible candidates were the election to be held now.

In violation of electoral legislation, he is actively campaigning using taxpayers' funds to jaunt around the country to inaugurate public works and make speeches criticizing the opposition and past government.

Thus far, he has had the stage to himself as officially and legally the political campaigns may not begin until July. The PSDB, known as the Tucanos (toucans), is the principal opposition party. They together with the conservative PFL and certain elements of the amorphous PMDB, ruled for eight years during the presidency of Fernando Henrique Cardoso, recognized by many as Brazil's best president since Juscelino Kubitschek.

The Tucanos and the PFL missed the boat by not being more outspoken in pointing out Lula's shortcomings during all these investigations, which by now after eight months have lost much of their steam as the populace tires of endless testimony and little concrete results.

The opposition did not want to be perceived as creating difficulties that would make it more difficult for Lula to govern. This attitude may have not been the proper behavior for them to adopt, as the recent surveys seem to indicate.

Brazilians have a short memory. Lula's popularity plummeted during the early days of the revelations of corruption and investigations. Several key officials of his Workers Party, (PT) including José Dirceu his Chief of Staff, were forced to resign. 

Land of Illiterates

It must be remembered that 70% of Brazil's population is functionally illiterate, according to published studies. With a population of 186 million, the IVC (Instituto Verificador de Circulação or Institute of Circulation Verification) shows that only 3.4 million read a daily newspaper.

While the press and the weekly news magazine Veja have been tireless in their coverage of the many scandals close to Lula, it seems that his support is intact among the low income masses and people with little education.

It may be difficult to dislodge Lula from his position as president. He has managed to allow sensible, although controversial, economic policy continue with the result that inflation is less than 4 or 5%, dependency on foreign loans has diminished and the IMF and Paris Club creditors have been paid off ahead of time.

The boom in exports can somewhat be attributed to high prices for some of Brazil's commodity exports, such as sugar and orange juice, and increased productivity in the industrial sector. Cell phones, passenger aircraft and autos have moved well for last couple of years.

However, the strengthening of the real is beginning to hurt many exporters as they earn less reais for their dollar or Euro denominated exports. I doubt if the spectacular rate of export growth can be maintained this year.

Politics and the World Cup will attract a great deal of attention diverting the government from facing the real problems of poor educational facilities, inadequate healthcare, crumbling infrastructure, an inefficient and archaic judicial system, excessive taxation and sky high interest rates.

Sales of tee shirts and TV sets, on the other hand, should be strong as the country gears up for these two major events.

The Tucanos have yet to decide who will be their candidate against Lula, presuming that he will run for reelection. The two most probable candidates are José Serra, currently mayor of São Paulo, and Geraldo Alckmin, governor of the State of São Paulo.

Serra ran and lost against Lula in 2002. When campaigning in 2004 for the post as mayor of South America's largest city, he stated that if elected he would finish out his four-year term, which now has more than two years to go. Should he give up his job as mayor to run for president, he would be a vulnerable target for the PT and others who could easily accuse him of being a liar.

Alckmin, not as well known outside the State of São Paulo as Serra, who was a good Minister of Health in the Cardoso government, in my opinion would be a better president. The question is "Could he win against Lula." In another week or so the Tucanos should announce who will be their candidate.

The Tucanos' logical partner, the PFL, is becoming impatient. Both the vice mayor and vice governor of São Paulo are PFL men who will take over if Serra leaves his post and certainly when Alckmin, who has already declared that he is running for president, steps down by the end of March as required by law. The PFL is backing Serra since it is anxious to get its hands on Brazil's third largest budget, the city of São Paulo, for more than two years.

The PSDB selection process is not democratic. It appears as if the Tucanos will leave it up to three men, Senator Tasso Jereissati the party president, the former president of the Republic, Fernando Henrique Cardoso, and Minas Gerais governor Aécio Neves to sort out which man of these two will be the Tucano standard bearer. Were the party at large to be consulted, Alckmin would no doubt be selected as some see Serra as a loser and he is not an agreeable person, so they say.

By fumbling around and possibly losing some support from the PFL, which naturally aspires to name the vice presidential candidate, the election may go to Lula. In my opinion, a combination of the competent, clean Alckmin and a PFL figure from the Northeast, where Lula is strong, will have the best chance of returning Brazil to better leadership than Lula and his cronies have displayed.

On a positive note, Brazil has reached self sufficiency in crude oil and is far ahead of the rest of the world in the use of ethanol, natural gas and biodiesel to fuel vehicles. The rating agencies such as Standard and Poor's and Fitch and Moody's have upgraded Brazilian debt paper making it less expensive to borrow abroad.

The local banks have reported record profits for 2005. The Bovespa, (São Paulo Stock Exchange) is setting record highs nearly every day. These are indications that Lula has not been the complete disaster than many feared. 

Richard Edward Hayes first came to Brazil in 1964 as an employee of Chase Manhattan Bank. Since then, Hayes has worked directly and as an advisor for a number of Brazilian and international banks and companies. Currently he is a free lance consultant and can be contacted at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (9)Add Comment
Any chance ther US will
written by Guest, March 06, 2006
become the next world cup champs?

Yeah, right! hehehe
...
written by Guest, March 07, 2006
Is this true?


It must be remembered that 70% of Brazil's population is functionally illiterate, according to published studies. With a population of 186 million, the IVC (Instituto Verificador de Circulação or Institute of Circulation Verification) shows that only 3.4 million read a daily newspaper.
Shock
written by Guest, March 07, 2006
There is an old saying that one must base his arguments on actual facts. Is it true that only 3.4 million Brazillians read newspapers. If that is the case the citizenry should demand better. Iraq under Saddam Hussein had a literacy rate of 95%, what are the leaders of Brazil doing.
Re: is this true
written by Guest, March 07, 2006
Yes. This statistic was compiled by the Instituto Paulo Montenegro (a branch of IBOPE, I think). The research's nuts and bolts are available in a 100-page .PDF on their website
WB, Mr. Hayes
written by Guest, March 07, 2006
The one fault with Mr. Hayes' articles is that they're not very frequent.

Regarding the congressional inquiries petering out and not finding anything, the latter does not surprise me, as, despite all the sound and fury of the hearings, no one was really interested in digging in too deep, as everyone there has skeletons in the closet (campaign or otherwise). Bluntly, this is how Brazil has always been run.

The inquiries did serve as mudslinging instruments though. Lula took a hit. However, the PT's tactics of picturing the whole system as corrupt proved more effective than I expected. The opposition's last card seems to be impeaching PT congressmen during the presidential election. Whether that will put a dent on Lula's candidacy remains to be seen.

I've had the displeasure of seeing Serra's arrogance first hand in a Brazilian hospital. My regard of his super-duper managerial competence is also low, and I fear his outdated, exotic economic ideas. Brazil should not repeat previous macroeconomic mistakes.

I also think that, frankly, believing in his promise to remain in office in São Paulo is naive. Considering that he always had presidential ambitions, having a running mate from the PFL is much more revealing of his intentions than a(nother) campaign promise.

Much of Brazil's status quo, in particular the purveyors of exotic monetary schemes, seems unaware of how much low inflation is popular among the poor, who have precious few defences against it. If you're in Brazil, try the following experiment: mention inflation to a poor person, say, your maid or a janitor, and see the look on his/her face...

Mr. Hayes is correct in his main point: 2006 should be another lost year, not only because of the vagaries of politics, but because the present lot has neither a grasp the problems he mentions nor the capacity to solve them.
Good Hayes !
written by Guest, March 07, 2006

You factually described Brazil reality.

But on Lula economic prowess, you are dead wrong !
You forgot to mention that due to the collapse of the currency, suddenly all brazilian exports became highly profitable. And the collpase of the currency earlier has nothing to do with Lula.
Another reason of the economic recovery was due to World demand, not du to Lula prowess.
This world demand was due because the U.S.A. decided to :
- put their interests rates at historic low.
- Accept US$ 600 billions and now over 700 billions in trade deficit.
- Create a huge budget deficit.
And these decisions created a world recovery, proofiting mostly the developing nations to whom Brazil belongs, amongst other nations.

This was not due to Lula either, but he got the benefits of decisions taken elsewhere...ONLY !

And as to his economy prowess, sorry but Lula failed miserably, lamentably !!!!!!
BECAUSE BRAZIL HAS THE LEAST ECONMOMIC GROWTH OF ALL DEVELOPING NATIONS, WETHER ON A 1 OR 3 YEARS BASIS. ON THE QUEUE OF THE QUEUE OF THEIR CLASSROOM !
But opbviously Lula compare his performance to the recent history AND NOT COMPARED TO HIS PEERS WHICH DID NOT DO ANY BETTER THAN BRAZIL BEFORE THE WORLD RECOVERY INITIATED BY THE USA....AND NOBODY ELSE !!! ANY ONE CAN GUESS WHY LULA IS COMPARING HIS PERFORMANCE WITH THE PAST AND NOT WITH HIS PEERS !!!!!

Finally no one should forget that Brazil has been nicknamed a BOOM AND BUST ECONOMY.
Therefore after having had a BOOM, A BUST should follow....!!!!!!
Unfortunately, due to Lula mismagements and failures, Brazil DID NOT get the REAL BOOM they should have had, just as the other developing nations HAD DURING THE LAST 3 YEARS !!!!

BRAZIL JUST LOST, ONCE MORE, THE OPPORTUNITY TO DEVELOP FAR MORE THAN THEY ACTUALLY DID.....DUE TO LULA FAILURES !!!!

AFTERALL NUMBERS ARE NUMBERS, EXCEPT LULA NUMBERS THAT ARE maniulated and taken out of context to hide the real truth !!!!!
LULA
written by Guest, March 11, 2006
I cannot believe that Brazilian would re-elect this drunk again!
70% Illiteracy? There is NO way to fix that, maybe in a million years. Where do these illiterate people come from mostly? Anyone's guess? Look North!
brazil
written by Guest, March 15, 2006
The right in this page care abouth the problem US is into. The people of us is well know overseas as "baby doll" because they believe in everything Bush says, Lula Drunk????? Well look the fact, I believe Mr Bush have problem with "Tequila, "DUI", unfortunately what's happening in brazil should stay in Brazil., The brazilian time is caming and i beliave the problem in this world is a problem with short memory .
Rahul,India
written by Guest, March 24, 2006
I didn know 70% of Brazilian are illeterate. Sorry to tell u guys but majority of site defamers belongs to brazil. How cum one group of people get so much competency while others live in fools paradise.

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smile
wink
laugh
grin
angry
sad
shocked
cool
tongue
kiss
cry
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack