After Two Years Brazil Gets Involved in Argentina-Uruguay Mill Dispute

    Argentineans protest against Uruguayan pulp plant

    Argentineans protest against Uruguayan pulp plant Brazil expressed complacence on Monday at the resumption of dialogue between Argentina and Uruguay regarding the dispute over the construction of a pulp mill by the Finnish company Botnia along a shared river between the two neighboring countries.

    "The Brazilian government is aware, with satisfaction of the results of the meeting between Argentina and Uruguay that took place in Madrid," under the auspices of King Juan Carlos from Spain, reads the official communiqué from the Brazilian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

    This is the first time Brazil has made public an official statement on the dispute which has been ongoing for almost two years and with the bilateral dialogue interrupted for twelve months.

    Brazil is pleased with the reestablishment of direct dialogue between both countries in an "atmosphere of mutual respect, sincerity and cordiality in the understanding that this step significantly contributes to the strengthening of Mercosur and South American integration".

    Uruguay and Argentina agreed last Friday to continue with the direct dialogue initiated in Madrid, under the auspice of the Spanish Crown with the purpose of finding a solution to the conflict triggered by the construction of pulp mills along border areas or jointly managed waterways.

    Uruguay and Argentina are committed to "abstain from adopting any measures or attitudes which could contribute to deepen existent differences or increase tensions", and to resume dialogue in a month's time, in a location yet to be determined by the "dialogue facilitator", Ambassador Juan Antonio Yaí±ez Barnuevo.

    The dialogue process will evolve at two levels, on the one hand with the participation of technical delegations that will advance in the different areas identified and when needed "with the presence and conduction" of staff with political responsibilities.

    The statement although expected, was as surprising as Brazil's passive attitude during the months' long dispute and its implicit siding with Argentina by preventing Uruguay on several occasions from taking the case to Mercosur.

    Uruguay wanted Mercosur to intervene and put an end to the pickets of environmentalists and Argentine residents from Gualeguaychu (across from where the Botnia-Orion is under construction in Uruguay), who have consistently blocked bridges linking both countries, and thus preventing the free flow of people and goods as stated in Mercosur founding chart.

    Time after time, Brazil supported the Argentine stance that the dispute was a bilateral issue between Argentina and Uruguay and therefore out of Mercosur agenda.

    Argentina (and pickets) claims the pulp mill will contaminate water and air and are demanding a relocation of the plant. Argentina is also protesting Uruguay's alleged attitude of ignoring a 1975 joint management of waterways agreement by unilaterally authorizing the Orion-Botnia plant construction.

    In related news protestors from Gualeguaychu took to the streets of Buenos Aires and released hundreds of broilers in front of Finland's embassy in Buenos Aires.

    "One of the main industries in our province Entre Rios is the poultry industry, with thousands of jobs, but once the pulp mills are in production nobody will want to eat chickens from our area", said one of the protestors.

    "Eat them now, before Botnia poisons them", said the protestors while giving away live chickens to pedestrians curious about the protest before the Finnish embassy.

    A delegation of picketers from the province of Entre Rios are scheduled to meet Tuesday in Buenos Aires with cabinet chief Alberto Fernández who was one of the negotiators in the bilateral talks in Madrid sponsored by the Spanish King.

    In spite of the optimism from both delegations regarding the resumption of dialogue following the talks in Madrid, pickets should continue blocking access to the three bridges linking Argentina with Uruguay.

    Mercopress

    Tags:

    • Show Comments (6)

    • Ric

      So, Pulp Fiction II?

    • swiss pride

      Ch.c
      YOU RIGHT…IT WAS STUPID!!! LAUGH LAUGH LAUGH

    • ch.c.

      Funny the article…..full of contradictions !
      1) the article headline :
      After Two Years Brazil Gets Involved in Argentina-Uruguay Mill Dispute

      2) the comments in the article :
      Brazil expressed complacence on Monday at the resumption of dialogue between Argentina and Uruguay regarding the dispute ……

      Stupid question :
      When did they finally get involved ???????

      LAUGH….LAUGH….LAUGH….!!!!

    • Dr. Wayne Dwernychuk

      Se. Scientist/Advisor; Hatfield Consultants; Canada
      I reviewed the Environmental Impact Statement for the World Bank. Argentina is completely wrong in their assertion of ‘irreparable’ environmental damage. Now there are claims the mill will taint the flesh of chickens … a laughable situation. This mill will be the most technically advanced in the world with inconsequential impacts. Argentina should look within their borders and rectify their own pulp mill pollution problems, which are substantial (on Rio Parana), and address these concerns with Paraguay … but no, they choose to completely blow out of proportion a benign situation on the Rio Uruguay for internal political gain … a reprehensible situation. Gualeguaychu protesters are taking their lead from their President who is only interested in political gain. If he was so interested in environmental issues in his country, he would have addressed the Rio Parana situation, and the disgusting pollution in BA in the Riachuelo-Metansa Basin … truly, the height of hypocrisy.

    • Ric

      They might want to spend a week in Tacoma first before deciding. Mushroom farms are worse but the smell doesn´t travel as far.

    • AES

      Oh woe to them that live down wind from a pulp mill
      Along the Atlantic along the south Georgia coast and north Florida the wind wafts with the sweet smell of baby dipers, it is the paper mills. Scent is so pervasive it is the air itself, it is like living next to a landfill, from which it is only through death or the deadening of consciousness that one can escape, or one can move. Perhaps the Finnish company has solved this particular problem of pulp mills, being so festidiously neat and tidy as all Scandinavian countries are, so well scrubbed.

      Brazil should stand as counsel in all disputes concerning South America. By sheer geography the concerns of South America concern Brazil, directly or indirectly.

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    comment *

    • name *

    • email *

    • website *

    Ads

    You May Also Like

    Now, 9.6% of Brazil’s Amazon Are Under Federal Protection

    Yesterday, June 5, on World Environment Day, the Brazilian government created three new conservation ...

    Brazil's Ethanol Summit

    Brazil Urges the US to Close Gap Between Rhetoric and Policy on Ethanol

    Today marks the last day of Brazil’s 2009 Ethanol Summit being held in São ...

    In a Risk Map Brazil Is Yellow Alert

    Control Risks Group, the international business risk consultancy, today launches RiskMap 2005, its annual ...

    The Death and the Death of the Patriarch

    Tieta, Teresa Batista, Gabriela, Quincas Berro Dágua, Vadinho and Dona Flor. For many of ...

    Cars at Volkswagen's lot

    Brazil’s Vehicle Production Falls 3.7% While Coffee Exports Rise 17%

    Compared with December of last year, Brazil’s vehicle production dropped by 3.7% in January. ...

    Brazilian Chancellor Sacks Critic and Puts Friend as Head of US Embassy

    The US State Department has already received the agrément from the Brazilian government with ...

    Deforestation in Brazil

    Brazil Says Amazon Deforestation Reached 20 Year Low

    The president of Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, announced that deforestation rates in ...

    Smiling Brazil to Bring Fluoridated Water to Half a Million People

    Around half a million Brazilians are about to receive the benefits of water fluoridation ...

    Volkswagen and GM Jump on Brazil’s Biodiesel Bandwagon

    Research for the use of biodiesel is progressing fast all around the world. A ...