Brazil Supreme Delays Decision on Giving Watchdog Agency Punitive Power

Brazilian Chief Justice Cezar Peluso Brazil’s Supreme Court has delayed a decision on the most eagerly awaited case on the docket: the question of the power of the National Justice Council, a government’s watchdog agency to punish judges.

The case is based on a lawsuit filed by an association of judges (Associação dos Magistrados Brasileiros – AMB) that seeks to limit administrative and, especially, correctional activities by the CNJ. The Chief Justice, Cezar Peluso, simply did not call up the case at Wednesday’s session.

According to justice Marco Aurélio Mello, who is handling the case, the postponement may have been an attempt to calm things down after declarations by Eliana Calmon, the Inspector General, that “bandits in togas were hiding in the judicial system.”

“This is just not the right moment to judge this case. We need to let things clear up a little more,” said Marco Aurélio.

However, another justice, Luiz Fux, said the only reason for not bringing up the AMB suit was a lack of time.

On the other hand, court observers raised the possibility of an attempt by the justices to reach a prior agreement and avoid a public argument.

Prior discussion of cases (called “conference” in the United States and a bedrock of US Supreme Court procedure) is not the rule in Brazil.

Justices reach their own opinions alone and express them separately in open court. Brazilian Supreme Court sessions can often feature verbal fireworks.

The idea of prior discussion is not universally popular among the justices. For example, justice Marco Aurélio Mello declared: “We should take our seats and express opinions spontaneously. There is no room for prior agreements on what we do in court. This is a courtroom, not a theater.”

When Chief Justice Cezar Peluso was asked after the session yesterday if there was a date for discussion of the AMB suit against punitive action by the CNJ, he just said it continued to be on the docket. That translates as: postponed until further notice.

ABr

Tags:

You May Also Like

Alcohol Makes Brazil Environment Friendly

Among the world’s three largest developing countries, China, India, and Brazil, Brazil has a ...

Brazil’s Beef Troubles: Russia Lifts Ban, EU May Impose Its Own

Brazilian beef exports are likely to rise in 2008 as Russia resumes importing meat ...

Already World’s Number 1, Brazil Expands Beef Export

Egypt and Saudi Arabia were among the ten main buyers of Brazilian raw cattle ...

Killing of Brazilian Shows London’s Police ‘Go for the Brain’ Policy

Jean Charles de Menezes, the 27-year-old Brazilian slain by police last week in a ...

Brazil Is World’s Second Poorest. 22 Million Are Indigent.

With a total of 53.9 million poor people (31.7%), about a third of the ...

Why We Failed: Brazil and World Politicians Can’t See Humanity, Only Voters

Everyone knows that the Copenhagen meeting failed in its attempt to impede the climate-change ...

Rio Tries to Ban Coconut Sales in the Beach. Measure Upsets Cariocas

Rio de Janeiro was about to lose one of its most enduring images, that ...

Mercosur Is Not Viable as Economic Bloc, Says Brazil’s Former Minister

"Mercosur has become irrelevant and too complicated, and even more when Venezuela is finally ...

Brazil’s Foreign Debt Shrinks, But It’s Still US$ 161 Billion

Brazil’s foreign debt in May was US$ 5.956 billion less than in March, according ...

Shooting Is All I Know –

Social exclusion and injustice are fundamental questions that led me to make City of ...